The Economics Of Coercion And Conflict

The Economics Of Coercion And Conflict
Author: Mark Harrison
Publisher: World Scientific
Total Pages: 441
Release: 2014-10-17
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 9814583359

The papers brought together in this volume represent a decade of advances in the historical political economy of defence, dictatorship, and warfare. They address defining events and institutions of the world in the twentieth century: economic consequences of repression and violence, the outcomes of two world wars, and the rise and fall of communism. They cross traditional disciplinary boundaries, combining a broad sweep with close attention to measurement and narrative detail; offering insights into these issues from economics, history, political science, and statistics; and demonstrating in action the value of a multi-disciplinary approach.The author was one of the first economists to leverage the opening of former Soviet archives. He has led international projects that reinvented the quantitative economics of the two world wars and contributed significantly to historical Soviet studies. In 2012, he shared with Andrei Markevich the Russian National Prize for Applied Economics, which was awarded in recognition of their research.

The Economics of Coercion and Conflict

The Economics of Coercion and Conflict
Author: Mark Harrison
Publisher:
Total Pages: 0
Release: 2013
Genre:
ISBN:

This chapter introduces the author's selected papers on the economics of coercion and conflict. It defines coercion and conflict and relates them. In conflict, adversaries make costly investments in the means of coercion. The application of coercion does not remove choice but limits it to options that leave the victim worse off than before. Coercion and conflict are always political, but a number of key concepts from economics can help us understand them. These include rational choice, strategic interaction, increasing and diminishing returns, scale and state capacity, surplus extraction, and Type I errors. The chapter concludes that the economist's toolkit, although not complete, is useful.

The Institutions of Economic Growth

The Institutions of Economic Growth
Author: John P. Powelson
Publisher: Princeton University Press
Total Pages: 292
Release: 2015-03-08
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 1400870763

Nations undergoing rapid economic growth require new institutions—both formal organizations and informal modes of interpersonal behavior. John Powelson develops a theory of institution-building to explain how nations choose such institutions, what kinds they prefer and why, and in what ways the institutions' effectiveness (essentially, their conflict-resolving capacity) may be measured. Originally published in 1972. The Princeton Legacy Library uses the latest print-on-demand technology to again make available previously out-of-print books from the distinguished backlist of Princeton University Press. These editions preserve the original texts of these important books while presenting them in durable paperback and hardcover editions. The goal of the Princeton Legacy Library is to vastly increase access to the rich scholarly heritage found in the thousands of books published by Princeton University Press since its founding in 1905.

Designing Economic Coercion

Designing Economic Coercion
Author: Monika A. Klimek
Publisher:
Total Pages: 80
Release: 2004
Genre: Economic sanctions
ISBN:

The vast literature on economic sanctions is dominated by studies that cast a shadow of doubt on their effectiveness to achieve foreign policy goals. Despite numerous studies on economic sanction effectiveness, little has been accomplished in building theoretical understanding as to why actors initiate and execute economic coercion. This thesis examines the use of economic sanctions by countries that are considered within the international community as middle powers . Ultimately, I test the theory of the middlepowerhood on countries that deployed sanctions from 1954-2000. Statistical results of a rare events logit support the conclusion that middle powers have distinctive characteristics for utilizing economic coercion. Also, by looking at the case study of Canada, I test Drezner's game theoretical model of conflict expectations. The results of a rare events logit model confirm the conflict expectations model, as the probability of sanction use is greater when escalation and magnitude of tensions increase. Finally, I build a model of sanction tactics that incorporates stages of deployment.

The Political Economy of Conflict and Appropriation

The Political Economy of Conflict and Appropriation
Author: Michelle R. Garfinkel
Publisher: Cambridge University Press
Total Pages: 194
Release: 1996-06-13
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 0521560632

Traditional economic analysis has concentrated on production and trading as the only means by which individual agents can increase their welfare. But both the history of industrialized countries and the current experience of many developing and transition economies suggest a major alternative: the appropriation of what others have produced through coercion, rent seeking, or influence peddling. Appropriation was how nobles, bandits, and kings used to make a living. The same is true nowadays for mafia bosses, army generals, lobbyists, and corrupt officials.

The Calculus of Conflict

The Calculus of Conflict
Author: Adam C. Smith
Publisher:
Total Pages: 0
Release: 2010
Genre: Conflict management
ISBN:

This dissertation addresses how we conceive of conflict from an opportunity cost perspective. Traditionally, economics posits the opportunity cost of choice as taking place in the context of tradeoffs between certain productive and consumptive uses of a person's resources, with this tradeoff taking place independently of the decisions of others. While this simple depiction of choice is suitable in markets where property rights are well-defined and outside coercion is minimal, it is ill-suited to contexts involving conflict. In conflictual environments, the opportunity cost of choice encompasses not only how the person allocates her resources to promote certain actions, but also how others will react to these actions. Thus, conflict by definition is nested within an interaction with others and therefore must be depicted as such when determining the opportunity cost considerations or calculus of conflict. The purpose of my first chapter is to explore the opportunity cost of conflict from this choice-theoretic perspective. This approach involves examining choice as it pertains to the person actually choosing whether to engage in conflict. My analysis is founded on a conception of conflict as being nested within an ongoing interaction with another person (or persons). This serves to expose a difficulty with modeling conflict from a strictly neoclassical perspective. Generally speaking, in the neoclassical style of argumentation, the decision-maker is described as choosing between two or more commodities/services where the relative prices are known. The opportunity cost of either item is the net gain associated with the foregone choice. Since the emphasis is placed upon resource scarcity as manifested through price differentials as the constraint of interest, negative consequences deriving from interaction with other person(s) merely lurk unstated in the background. As a result, the standard neoclassical approach, which has greatly influenced benefit-cost analysis and other decision models, obscures the disincentives these consequences place upon particular individuals considering acts of conflict. The contribution of this paper is to analytically distinguish the costs that pertain to (1) resource allocation and (2) the interaction with other persons. I draw out these costs by using an opportunity cost framework that builds upon the work of such theorists as Armen Alchian, James Buchanan, Jack Hirshleifer, and Murray Rothbard. My framework exposes the effects of these consequences upon behavior, which constitute crucial disincentives to engage in conflict, limiting its incidence even when no external enforcement is present. Furthermore, I present evidence from several contributions in the new comparative political economy literature that serve to expose how cooperation emerges as a result of the negative consequences of conflict with others. I next more rigorously define my model and test it using a laboratory experiment. I examine each of these constraints upon conflict, those that derive from resource scarcity and those that derive from the consequences of interaction with others. In this expansion upon previous theoretical and experimental efforts, I incorporate more fully both constraints into the participant's opportunity cost of choosing conflict by linking effort levels in the form of amount of arming and the level of destruction of a contestable resource. I employ an experiment to learn how alteration of these constraints changes outcomes in practice. I find that subjects follow the theoretical predictions in that severing the link between effort level and destruction leads to a 32.29% greater incidence of conflict. I also find a counter-intuitive effect produced by increasing the price of arming: an increase in the price of arms results in a 17.08% increase in the incidence of conflict. These results illustrate that the incidence of conflict is affected by both constraints in tandem as greater resource scarcity alone does not necessitate lower levels of conflict. As I demonstrate, how one models the nested interaction in which conflict takes place ultimately determines the opportunity cost of choosing conflict. Finally, I apply my framework to the changes in our current political landscape motivated by the recent financial crisis. This paper demonstrates that while policymakers ostensibly claim to be shifting market enterprises towards politically salient objectives, what occurs in practice is an interaction across competing networks of political and market enterprises. This embedded web of relationships inevitably influences actual political outcomes in a direction that no one organization can control or predict. One such outcome, the creation of the Troubled Assets Relief Program (TARP), illustrates the central thesis of my dissertation. While TARP reduced the costs in resources of gaining political advantages such as extensive subsidies and government support, the resulting backlash from this same mechanism caused market enterprises to reduce their involvement with political enterprises to minimum mandated levels. Furthermore, these companies chose to exit TARP oversight as soon as was legally feasible, an outcome which runs counter to a prediction that relies solely on the observation of decreased resource costs. After all, if the costs of rent-seeking decrease, a simpler model would predict greater rent-seeking. Incorporating the interactive costs of conflict reconciles the observed behavior of firms with economic theory. In summary, by exposing the interactive nature of conflict, this dissertation demonstrates that resource allocation across productive possibilities is only part of the calculus of conflict. Participants engaging in acts of conflict must reckon with the actions of others. The importance of this contribution is that it reveals that a decrease in the cost of resources used in conflict does not necessitate an increase in the incidence of conflict, as a naïve application of standard demand theory would predict. Instead, the more comprehensive opportunity cost framework I employ shows that it is only when we account for both the costs of these resources and the costs due to the interaction itself that we can apply the law of demand. The implication for research in conflict theory is that the objective resource costs of conflict must be analyzed alongside of the interactive costs of conflict when determining actual incidence of conflict. Incorporating these interactive costs yields a far more optimistic outlook of the ability of persons to cooperate, even under the direst of circumstances, such as takes place in environments characterized by conflict and violence.

The Oxford Handbook of the Economics of Peace and Conflict

The Oxford Handbook of the Economics of Peace and Conflict
Author: Michelle R. Garfinkel
Publisher: OUP USA
Total Pages: 889
Release: 2012-04-20
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 0195392779

This Handbook brings together contributions from leading scholars who take an economic perspective to study peace and conflict. Some chapters are largely empirical, exploring the correlates and quantifying the costs of conflict. Others are more theoretical, examining the mechanisms that lead to war or are more conducive to peace.

Coercion, Survival, and War

Coercion, Survival, and War
Author: Phil Haun
Publisher: Stanford University Press
Total Pages: 286
Release: 2015-07-01
Genre: Political Science
ISBN: 080479507X

In asymmetric interstate conflicts, great powers have the capability to coerce weak states by threatening their survival—but not vice versa. It is therefore the great power that decides whether to escalate a conflict into a crisis by adopting a coercive strategy. In practice, however, the coercive strategies of the U.S. have frequently failed. In Coercion, Survival and War Phil Haun chronicles 30 asymmetric interstate crises involving the US from 1918 to 2003. The U.S. chose coercive strategies in 23 of these cases, but coercion failed half of the time: most often because the more powerful U.S. made demands that threatened the very survival of the weak state, causing it to resist as long as it had the means to do so. It is an unfortunate paradox Haun notes that, where the U.S. may prefer brute force to coercion, these power asymmetries may well lead it to first attempt coercive strategies that are expected to fail in order to justify the war it desires. He concludes that, when coercion is preferred to brute force there are clear limits as to what can be demanded. In such cases, he suggests, U.S. policymakers can improve the chances of success by matching appropriate threats to demands, by including other great powers in the coercive process, and by reducing a weak state leader's reputational costs by giving him or her face-saving options.