Executive Stock Options, Firm Performance and Risk

Executive Stock Options, Firm Performance and Risk
Author: Allan McCall
Publisher:
Total Pages:
Release: 2013
Genre:
ISBN:

This dissertation comprises two essays on the use of stock options as compensation. In the first I examine the implementation of stock option plans in the 1950s as a natural experiment through which to examine the incentive implications of stock options. In the 1950 Revenue Act, Congress created "restricted stock options" that received favorable tax treatment compared to other forms of compensation. Immediately prior to change in tax law, there was almost no use of stock options for compensation. Over subsequent years, the majority of firms in my sample implement stock option plans. I find evidence that executives appear to respond to stock option plans by increasing firm risk and decreasing dividend payments. However, I do not find that firms implementing stock option plans subsequently perform better, and in fact find that in terms of ROA, they perform worse over the two years after putting a stock option plan in place. The second essay examines the economic consequences associated with the board of director choice of whether to adhere to proxy advisory firm policies in the design of stock option repricing programs. Proxy advisors provide research and voting recommendations to institutional investors on issues subject to a shareholder vote. Since many institutional investors follow the recommendations of proxy advisors in their voting, proxy advisor policies are an important consideration for corporate boards in the development of programs that require shareholder approval such as stock option repricing programs. Using a comprehensive sample of stock option repricings announced between 2004 and 2009, we find that repricing firms following the restrictive policies of proxy advisors exhibit statistically lower market reaction to the repricing, lower operating performance, and higher employee turnover. These results are consistent with the conclusion that proxy advisory firm recommendations regarding stock option repricings are not value increasing for shareholders.

Non-Executive Stock Options and Firm Performance

Non-Executive Stock Options and Firm Performance
Author: Yael V. Hochberg
Publisher:
Total Pages: 34
Release: 2016
Genre:
ISBN:

We examine whether options granted to rank and file employees have effects on the performance of the firm, by exploring the link between broad-based option grants, option portfolio implied incentives and firm operating performance. We employ an instrumental variables approach that combines information about the labor market characteristics in which firms compete with information on firm option programs from the Investor Responsibility Research Center to identify causal effects. Firms that broadly grant options to non-executive employees exhibit higher operating performance than firms that do not grant options broadly. We find a similar positive relationship between the implied incentives of the portfolio of outstanding non-executive options and subsequent firm operating performance. Consistent with economic theory, we find that the incentive-performance effect is larger in smaller firms, and in firms with higher growth opportunities and higher growth options per employee. Finally, we find that the performance effect is concentrated solely in firms that grant options broadly to non-executive employees, supporting the argument that options may induce monitoring among co-workers.

Do Executive Stock Option Grants Have Value Implications for Firm Performance?

Do Executive Stock Option Grants Have Value Implications for Firm Performance?
Author: Swee Sum Lam
Publisher:
Total Pages:
Release: 2006
Genre:
ISBN:

Consistent with predictions of agency theory, we find direct evidence that executive stock option grants have value implications for firm performance. This inference is drawn from evaluation of various motivations for the use of such grants in executive compensation: value enhancement, risk taking, tax benefit, signaling and cash conservation. We find consistent evidence for the value enhancement motivation to reduce agency costs. As well, they signal for positive price sensitive information. Our results reject the tax benefit and cash conservation motivations. This finding is robust after controlling for the endogenous character of executive stock option grants and other equity-based grants.

Pay Without Performance

Pay Without Performance
Author: Lucian A. Bebchuk
Publisher: Harvard University Press
Total Pages: 308
Release: 2004
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 9780674020634

The company is under-performing, its share price is trailing, and the CEO gets...a multi-million-dollar raise. This story is familiar, for good reason: as this book clearly demonstrates, structural flaws in corporate governance have produced widespread distortions in executive pay. Pay without Performance presents a disconcerting portrait of managers' influence over their own pay--and of a governance system that must fundamentally change if firms are to be managed in the interest of shareholders. Lucian Bebchuk and Jesse Fried demonstrate that corporate boards have persistently failed to negotiate at arm's length with the executives they are meant to oversee. They give a richly detailed account of how pay practices--from option plans to retirement benefits--have decoupled compensation from performance and have camouflaged both the amount and performance-insensitivity of pay. Executives' unwonted influence over their compensation has hurt shareholders by increasing pay levels and, even more importantly, by leading to practices that dilute and distort managers' incentives. This book identifies basic problems with our current reliance on boards as guardians of shareholder interests. And the solution, the authors argue, is not merely to make these boards more independent of executives as recent reforms attempt to do. Rather, boards should also be made more dependent on shareholders by eliminating the arrangements that entrench directors and insulate them from their shareholders. A powerful critique of executive compensation and corporate governance, Pay without Performance points the way to restoring corporate integrity and improving corporate performance.

The Pay to Performance Incentives of Executive Stock Options

The Pay to Performance Incentives of Executive Stock Options
Author: Brian J. Hall
Publisher:
Total Pages: 60
Release: 1998
Genre: Chief executive officers
ISBN:

Detailed data about stock option contracts are used to measure and analyze the pay to performance incentives of executive stock options. Two main issues are addressed. The first is the pay to performance incentives created by the revaluation of stock option holdings. The findings suggest that if CEO stock holdings were replaced by the same ex ante value of stock options, the pay to performance sensitivity of the median CEO would approximately double. Relative to granting at the money options, a value neutral policy of regularly granting options out of the money (Pe=1.5P) would increase pay to performance sensitivity by approximately 27 percent. The second issue is the pay to performance created by yearly stock option grants. Because most stock option plans are multi year plans, it is shown that different option granting plans have significantly different pay to performance incentives since changes in current stock prices affect the value of future option grants in different ways. Four option granting policies are compared and contrasted. Ranked from highest powered to lowest powered, these policies are: 1) LBO-style up-front options, 2) fixed number policies, 3) fixed value policies and 4) an (unofficial) policy of "back-door repricing." Empirical evidence suggests that (even ignoring the revaluation of past option grants) the pay to performance relationship in practice is stronger for 1) stock option grants relative to salary and bonus, and 2) fixed number plans relative to non-fixed number plans.

Incentives, Targeting and Firm Performance

Incentives, Targeting and Firm Performance
Author: Yael V. Hochberg
Publisher:
Total Pages: 44
Release: 2016
Genre:
ISBN:

We examine whether options granted to non-executive employees affect firm performance. Using new data on option programs, we explore the link between broad-based option programs, option portfolio implied incentives, and firm operating performance, utilizing an instrumental variables approach to identify causal effects. Firms whose employee option portfolios have higher implied incentives exhibit higher subsequent operating performance. Intuitively, the implied incentive-performance relation is concentrated in firms with fewer employees and in firms with higher growth opportunities. Additionally, the effect is concentrated in firms that grant options broadly to non-executive employees, consistent with theories of cooperation and mutual monitoring among co-workers.

Stock Option Incentives and Firm Performance

Stock Option Incentives and Firm Performance
Author: Stephen A. Hillegeist
Publisher:
Total Pages: 51
Release: 2004
Genre:
ISBN:

This paper analyzes the performance consequences of employee stock options for a broad sample of firms during the period 1996-1999. Our tests are performed separately for the top-5 executives and all other employees. We estimate the expected level of option incentives based on each firm's economic characteristics. We examine the association between the unexpected level of option incentives and firm performance as measured by future abnormal returns, future return on assets, and current and future firm value (Tobin's Q). We find consistent evidence that firms with unexpectedly high levels of option incentives exhibit significantly higher levels of firm performance. The results hold for both Executives and Employees and are consistent across each of our three measures of firm performance.

Executive Compensation and Shareholder Value

Executive Compensation and Shareholder Value
Author: Jennifer Carpenter
Publisher: Springer Science & Business Media
Total Pages: 159
Release: 2013-04-17
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 1475751923

Executive compensation has gained widespread public attention in recent years, with the pay of top U.S. executives reaching unprecedented levels compared either with past levels, with the remuneration of top executives in other countries, or with the wages and salaries of typical employees. The extraordinary levels of executive compensation have been achieved at a time when U.S. public companies have realized substantial gains in stock market value. Many have cited this as evidence that U.S. executive compensation works well, rewarding managers who make difficult decisions that lead to higher shareholder values, while others have argued that the overly generous salaries and benefits bear little relation to company performance. Recent conceptual and empirical research permits for the first time a truly rigorous debate on these and related issues, which is the subject of this volume.