Three Essays on Networks and Public Economics

Three Essays on Networks and Public Economics
Author: Pier-André Bouchard St Amant
Publisher:
Total Pages: 336
Release: 2013
Genre:
ISBN:

This thesis is a collection of three essays. The first two study how ideas spread through a network of individuals, and how it an advertiser can exploit it. In the model I develop, users choose their sources of information based on the perceived usefulness of their sources of information. This contrasts with previous literature where there is no choice made by network users and thus, the information flow is fixed. I provide a complete theoretical characterization of the solution and define a natural measure of influence based on choices of users. I also present an algorithm to solve the model in polynomial time on any network, regardless of the scale or the topology. I also discuss the properties of a network technology from a public economic standpoint. In essence, a network allows the reproduction of ideas for free for the advertiser. If there is any free-riding problem, I show that coalitions of users on the network can solve such problem. I also discuss the social value of networks, a value that cannot be captured for profit. The third essay is completely distinct from the network paradigm and instead studies funding rules for public universities. I show that a funding rule that depends solely on enrolment leads to "competition by franchise" and that such behavior is sometimes inefficient. I suggest instead an alternate funding rule that allows government to increase welfare without increasing spending in universities.

New Frontiers in the Economics of Innovation and New Technology

New Frontiers in the Economics of Innovation and New Technology
Author: Cristiano Antonelli
Publisher: Edward Elgar Publishing
Total Pages: 495
Release: 2006-01-01
Genre: Technology & Engineering
ISBN: 1845427920

This Festschrift explores the truly exceptional breadth and depth of Paul David s work, focusing upon his contributions to the topics of path dependence, the economics of knowledge, and the diffusion of technology. The book consists of 15 papers plus an introduction by the editors and an entertaining postscript by Dominique Foray. . . For economic historians, the papers on path dependence assembled in this book, and particularly the conceptual paper by Antonelli, should be essential reading. Nikolaus Wolf, Economic History Review Recent research on the economics of innovation has acknowledged the importance of path dependence and networks in the evolution of economies and the diffusion of new techniques, products, and processes. These are topics pioneered by Paul A. David, one of the world s leading scholars in the economics of innovation. This outstanding collection provides a fitting tribute to the diversity and depth of Paul David s contributions. The papers included range from simulation models of the evolution of market structure in the presence of innovation, through historical investigations of knowledge networks and empirical analysis of contemporary networks, to the analysis of the diffusion of innovations using simulation and analytic models and of the diffusion of knowledge using patent data. With an emphasis on simulation models, data analysis, and historical evidence, this book will be required reading for researchers in innovation economics and regional development as well as economists, sociologists, and historians of innovation and intellectual property.

Essays on Economic Networks

Essays on Economic Networks
Author: Hemant Patil
Publisher:
Total Pages: 108
Release: 2008
Genre:
ISBN:

In the first Essay, we present a model in which buyers and sellers use links to trade with each other. Each seller produces a good which can be one of two types. Buyers are ex ante identical but receive specification or valuation shocks after the links are formed. We show that efficient networks are stable and that severing a link in an efficient network results in a higher price for the buyer but a lower price for the seller. We also examine network intermediation when sellers (buyers) form links sequentially. When sellers form links sequentially, the first seller becomes an intermediary and shares links with other sellers; this makes all sellers better off. However, when buyers form links sequentially, buyers may or may not share links. If links are shared multiple intermediaries result. Second essay studies the social networks of economic publishing. We focus on connections between the editors of the journal and the authors of the paper. The links between authors and editors are defined based on their institutional ties. We provide a model in which non-linked authors do not have access to the exact quality standards at the journal as opposed to the linked authors who have such information. We show how such asymmetry coupled with measurement errors associated with quality leads to fewer low quality papers published by the linked authors. We support this finding empirically using data from ten top economic journals. We also show that if links are classified using the identity of nodes such as authors being students or faculty members in an institution then there are significant variations among journals with regard to the information dissemination through different types of links. In the third essay, we present a model in which agents use links to trade with each other. We divide the agents into two categories stayers and travellers. Stayers cannot travel whereas travellers can travel to the stayers to exchange. There are three types of goods. Stayers are subject to endowment shock which determines the type of one indivisible unit of the good is determined. Travellers are subject to preference shock wherein the type of good they prefer for consumption is determined. Travellers cannot travel to the stayer unless they have a prior link. In such environment, we determine the optimum travel patterns in a complete network and show that the set of possible Nash equilibria support both Walrasian exchange and commodity money for shocks which do not support double coincidence of wants. We also show the efficient link patterns which support optimum travel strategies and determine the stability of such link patterns.

Essays on Economic Networks

Essays on Economic Networks
Author: Benjamin Golub
Publisher:
Total Pages:
Release: 2011
Genre:
ISBN:

This dissertation theoretically analyzes how networks of relationships among decision-makers affect two kinds of economic processes: (i) investment in public goods; and (ii) repeated updating of beliefs or behaviors based on observing neighbors. The results connect these processes to the spectral properties of networks -- that is, eigenvalues and eigenvectors -- and use the connection to shed light on economic outcomes. The first essay, based on joint work with Matthew Elliott, focuses on games in which each player simultaneously exerts costly effort that provides different benefits to each other player. The goal is to find and describe effort profiles that are immune to coordinated coalitional deviations when such a game is played repeatedly. Formally, these effort profiles are the ones that can be sustained in a strong Nash equilibrium of the repeated game. We introduce a class of effort profiles that are called centrality-stable. These are characterized by a network centrality condition: agent A's contribution (defined as effort level times marginal cost) is equal to a weighted sum of the contributions of those who help A; the weight on B's contribution measures the marginal benefit B's effort provides to A. Under certain assumptions (mainly concavity of utility functions), centrality-stable profiles exist, are Pareto-efficient, and any such profile is sustainable in a coalitionally robust equilibrium of the repeated game. Centrality-stable profiles also have an alternative definition: they are those at which all agents are first-order indifferent to scaling all efforts by a factor near $1$. This single condition rules out all profitable coalitional deviations. The results are obtained without parametric assumptions, using the theory of general equilibrium and its relation to the core, along with the Perron-Frobenius spectral theory of nonnegative matrices. When agents are uncertain about each other's utility functions but can verify marginal costs and benefits at an implemented effort profile, then the centrality-stable profiles are the only ones that are immune to manipulation through misreporting of preferences. The second essay, based on joint work with Matthew O. Jackson, studies learning in a setting where agents receive independent noisy signals about the true value of a variable and then communicate in a network. They naively update beliefs by repeatedly taking weighted averages of neighbors' opinions. We show that all opinions in a large society converge to the truth if and only if the influence of the most influential agent on the long-run beliefs vanishes as the society grows. We also identify obstructions to this, including the existence of prominent groups, and provide structural conditions on the network ensuring efficient learning. The third essay, also based on joint work with Matthew O. Jackson, examines how the speed of such an updating process depends on homophily: the tendency of agents to associate disproportionately with those having similar traits. When agents' beliefs or behaviors are developed by averaging what they see among their neighbors -- as in the learning model discussed above or in a myopic best-reply dynamic -- convergence to a consensus is slowed by the presence of homophily, but is not influenced by network density. This is in stark contrast to the viral spread of a belief or behavior along shortest paths -- a process whose speed is increasing in network density but does not depend on homophily. In deriving these results, we propose a new, general spectral measure of homophily based on the relative frequencies of interactions among different groups.

Economics of Standards in Information Networks

Economics of Standards in Information Networks
Author: Tim Weitzel
Publisher: Springer Science & Business Media
Total Pages: 308
Release: 2012-12-06
Genre: Computers
ISBN: 3790826642

Standards play a prominent role in systems characterized by interaction. In information systems, standards provide for compatibility and are a prerequisite for collaboration benefits. More generally speaking, standards constitute networks. In this work, a standardization framework based on an analysis of deficiencies of network effect theory and a game theoretic network equilibrium analysis is developed. Fundamental determinants of diffusion processes in networks (e.g. network topology, agent size, installed base) are identified and incorporated into a computer-based simulation model. As a result, typical network behaviour (specific diffusion patterns) can be explained and many findings from traditional network effect theory can be described as special cases of the model at particular parameter constellations (e.g. low price, high density). On this basis, solution strategies for standardization problems are developed, and a methodological path towards a unified theory of networks is proposed.