Networks Effects, Nonlinear Pricing and Entry Deterrence

Networks Effects, Nonlinear Pricing and Entry Deterrence
Author: Arun Sundararajan
Publisher:
Total Pages: 34
Release: 2009
Genre:
ISBN:

A number of technology products display positive network effects, and are used invariable quantities by heterogeneous customers. Examples include operating systems, infrastructureand back-end software, web services and networking equipment. This paper studies optimalnonlinear pricing for such products, under incomplete information, and with the threat of competitiveentry. Both homogeneous and heterogeneous network effects are modeled. Conditions underwhich a fulfilled-expectations contract exists and is unique are established. While network effectsgenerally raise price, it is shown that accompanying changes in consumption depend on the natureof the network effects - in some cases, it is optimal for the monopolist to induce no changes in usageacross customers, while in others cases, network effects raise the usage of all market participants.Optimal pricing is shown to include quantity discounts that increase with usage, and may also involvea nonlinear two-part tariff. These results highlight the impact of network effects on trade-offsbetween price discrimination and value creation, and have important managerial implications forpricing policy in technology markets.The need to deter competitive entry generally lowers profits for the monopolist, and increasescustomer surplus. When network effects are homogeneous across customers, the resulting entry-deterringmonopoly contract is a fixed fee and results in the socially optimal outcome. However,when the magnitude of heterogeneous network effects is relatively high, there are no changes intotal surplus induced by the entry threat, and the price changes merely cause a transfer of valuefrom the seller to its customers. The presence of network effects, and of a credible entry threat, arealso shown to increase distributional efficiency by reducing the disparity in relative value capturedby different customer types. Regulatory and policy implications of these results are discussed.

Network Effects, Nonlinear Pricing and Entry Deterrence

Network Effects, Nonlinear Pricing and Entry Deterrence
Author: Arun Sundararajan
Publisher:
Total Pages: 42
Release: 2008
Genre:
ISBN:

A number of products that display positive network effects are used in variable quantities by heterogeneous customers. Examples include corporate operating systems, infrastructure software, web services and networking equipment. In many of these contexts, the magnitude of network effects are influenced by gross consumption, rather than simply by user base. Moreover, the value an individual customer derives on account of these network effects may be related to the extent of their individual consumption,and therefore, the network effects may be heterogeneous across customers.This paper presents a model of nonlinear pricing in the presence of such network effects, under incomplete information, and with the threat of competitive entry. Both homogeneous and heterogeneous network effectsare modeled. Conditions under which a fulfilled-expectations contract exists and is unique are established. While network effects generally raise prices, it is shown that accompanying changes in consumption dependon the nature of the network effects in some cases, it is optimal for the monopolist to induce no changes in usage across customers, while in others cases, network effects raise the usage of all market participants. Optimal pricing is shown to include quantity discounts that increase with usage, and may also involve a nonlinear two-part tariff. These results highlight the impact of network effects on the standard trade-off between price discrimination and value creation, and have important implications for pricing policy.The threat of entry generally lowers profits for the monopolist, and increases customer surplus. When network effects are homogeneous across customers, the resulting entry-deterring monopoly contract is a fixedfee and results in the socially optimal outcome. However, when the magnitude of heterogeneous network effects is relatively high, there are no changes in total surplus induced by the entry threat, and the pricechanges merely cause a transfer of value from the seller to its customers. The presence of network effects, and of a credible entry threat, are also shown to increase distributional efficiency by reducing the disparity in relative value captured by different customer types. Regulatory and policy implications of these resultsare discussed.

Nonlinear Pricing with Local Network Effects

Nonlinear Pricing with Local Network Effects
Author: Arne Gramstad
Publisher:
Total Pages: 33
Release: 2016
Genre:
ISBN:

This paper presents a model of second-degree price discrimination by a monopolistic seller who offers a menu of price-quantity pair contracts to consumers located in a social network. Network effects are local as consumers' private valuations are increasing in their friends' adoption decisions. When designing the optimal set of contracts, the seller takes into account how these local network effects are generated over the social network. Increased participation generates externalities through a ''market size effect'' (higher participation due to higher valuations) and a ''distribution effect'' (consumers upgrade to a higher quantity contract). Local network effects can induce the seller to offer contracts to some consumer segments at a loss (e.g., by offering a free-of-charge plan). Due to the combination of network effects and asymmetric information a complete market failure can occur, i.e., no output is produced despite some production is socially desirable.

Empirical Analysis of Network Effects

Empirical Analysis of Network Effects
Author: Angélique Augereau
Publisher:
Total Pages:
Release: 1999
Genre:
ISBN:

The last chapter addresses a firm's motivation to join an informal network in the context of a standards war. I examine the importance of compatibility and network effects on technology adoption decisions of suppliers of Internet access as they upgrade to a new high speed modem standard. The results confirm the strong influence of network effects on adoption of new technologies.

Indirect Network Effects in New Product Growth

Indirect Network Effects in New Product Growth
Author: S. Stremersch
Publisher:
Total Pages: 0
Release: 2013
Genre:
ISBN:

Indirect network effects are of prime interest to marketers because they affect the growth and takeoff of software availability for, and hardware sales of, a new product. While prior work on indirect network effects in the economics and marketing literature is valuable, these literatures show two main shortcomings. First, empirical analysis of indirect network effects is rare. Second, in contrast to the importance the prior literature credits to the chicken-and-egg paradox in these markets, the temporal pattern - which leads which? - of indirect network effects remains unstudied. Based on empirical evidence of nine markets, this study shows, among others, that: (1) indirect network effects, as commonly operationalized by prior literature, are weaker than expected from prior literature; (2) in most markets we examined, hardware sales leads software availability, while the reverse almost never happens, contradicting existing beliefs. These findings are supported by multiple methods, such as takeoff and time series analyses, and fit with the histories of the markets we studied. The findings have important implications for academia, public policy and management practice. To academia, it identifies a need for new, and more relevant, conceptualizations of indirect network effects. To public policy, it questions the need for intervention in network markets. To management practice, it downplays the importance of the availability of a large library of software for hardware technology to be successful.

The Econometric Analysis of Network Data

The Econometric Analysis of Network Data
Author: Bryan Graham
Publisher: Academic Press
Total Pages: 246
Release: 2020-05-15
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 0128117729

The Econometric Analysis of Network Data serves as an entry point for advanced students, researchers, and data scientists seeking to perform effective analyses of networks, especially inference problems. It introduces the key results and ideas in an accessible, yet rigorous way. While a multi-contributor reference, the work is tightly focused and disciplined, providing latitude for varied specialties in one authorial voice. - Answers both 'why' and 'how' questions in network analysis, bridging the gap between practice and theory allowing for the easier entry of novices into complex technical literature and computation - Fully describes multiple worked examples from the literature and beyond, allowing empirical researchers and data scientists to quickly access the 'state of the art' versioned for their domain environment, saving them time and money - Disciplined structure provides latitude for multiple sources of expertise while retaining an integrated and pedagogically focused authorial voice, ensuring smooth transition and easy progression for readers - Fully supported by companion site code repository - 40+ diagrams of 'networks in the wild' help visually summarize key points

The Economics of Networks - A Survey of the Empirical Literature

The Economics of Networks - A Survey of the Empirical Literature
Author: Daniel Birke
Publisher:
Total Pages: 33
Release: 2013
Genre:
ISBN:

Network effects, the increase in value of consuming a product if many other consumers use the same product, is a feature of many markets of high-technology products. Frequently cited examples of products exhibiting network effects are telecommunication or software products. This paper surveys the burgeoning empirical literature that has developed especially during the last years. After theoretical work dominated the earlier years of research in this area, newer research has combined theoretical models with empirical studies and applied work with direct implications for marketing and public policy. Furthermore, insights from the study of social networks have been applied to analyse how consumers interact with each other. The paper argues that a closer analysis of the network structure of consumer interaction promises fruitful future research avenues and advances in our understanding of how network effects operate.

Essay on Network Effects, Consumer Demand, and Firms' Dynamic Pricing

Essay on Network Effects, Consumer Demand, and Firms' Dynamic Pricing
Author: Rong Luo
Publisher:
Total Pages:
Release: 2015
Genre:
ISBN:

This dissertation includes three chapters on estimating structural economics models. My research focuses on empirically study consumers' utility from different products, the impact of network effects on consumers' demand for products, and multi-network firms' dynamic pricing strategies. The three chapters share the same feature of estimating a discrete choice demand model, but differ in the static versus dynamic setting and the underlying economics question and strategic behaviors that I'm interested.Chapter 1"The Operating System Network Effect and Telecom Carriers' Dynamic Pricing of Smartphones."The utility a consumer realizes from owning a smartphone increases with its operating system (OS) network size. Due to this OS network effect, multi-network telecom carriers have a different pricing strategy for smartphones than the single- network manufacturers in a dynamic environment. While manufacturers choose higher prices for larger networks, carriers, who can internalize competition across OSs, have incentives to choose lower prices for larger networks. The carriers' pricing strategy contributes to the increasing smartphone users and OS concentration. In this paper, I first analyze a theoretical model to compare the pricing strategies of the carriers and manufacturers. Then I design a structural model of consumers' demand and the carriers' dynamic pricing game for smartphones, and empirically study the impact of the OS network effect and carriers' two-year contract policy on the smartphone market penetration and OS concentration. I estimate the model using product level data from August 2011 to July 2013 in the US. I deal with the empirical challenges of dynamic prices for multi-product carriers, high dimension continuous state variables, and asymmetric oligopolistic firms in the estimation. The results show that the OS network size has a positive and significant impact on consumer utility. I then study two counterfactual cases in which I eliminate the OS network effect and the carriers' pricing strategy, respectively. I find that, without the OS network effect, the smartphone penetration rate would decrease by 54.7% and the largest OS share difference decrease by 31.7% by May 2013. Without the carriers' pricing strategy, the penetration rate would decrease by 29.1% and the OS market share difference decrease by 11.2%.Chapter 2"The Operating System Network Effect and Consumers' Dynamic Demand of Smartphones with Two-Year Contracts."This paper studies consumers' dynamic demand of smartphones on two-year wireless contracts. Individuals' demand decisions are affected by the improving quality and changing prices of smartphones, and the OS network effect, and their current smartphone contract status. Consumers need to pay high early termination fees if they end active contracts. The dynamic demand model in this paper incorporates the evolving choice set, prices, endogenous OS network sizes, and the termination policies in the smartphone industry. The preliminary results find that the OS network effect is large and significant. In addition, compared with dynamic model results, a static demand model tends to underestimate the OS network effect and overestimate price coefficient.Chapter 3"Store Brands and Retail Grocery Competition in Breakfast Cereals."This paper empirically analyzes the impacts of store brands on grocery retailers and consumers in the market for breakfast cereals. On the supply side, store brands help a retailer to avoid direct competition with other retailers and change the set of retailer's products. On the demand side, introducing store brands changes the national brands prices and consumers' choice set. We analyze the effects via demand estimation for a single grocery store chain Dominick's at Chicago in 1997 and counterfactual exercises. The estimation results show that consumers' unobserved utility of buying at a competing retailer is higher for consumers that value national brands, and is lower for ones that value Dominick's store brands. This is consistent with the claim that store brands help a retailer to avoid competition. The counterfactual calculations show that the profit loss from removing store brands is higher if the retailer has more competitors, with a median loss of 4.33% of profits from cereals. Existence of store brands increases national brands prices and consumer welfare increases slightly when store brands are removed.