Understanding the Borderwork of the EU's Mainstreamed Migration Control-development Cooperation Agenda Through the EU Emergency Trust Fund for Africa Instrument

Understanding the Borderwork of the EU's Mainstreamed Migration Control-development Cooperation Agenda Through the EU Emergency Trust Fund for Africa Instrument
Author: Jana Walkowski
Publisher:
Total Pages:
Release: 2021
Genre:
ISBN:

"One of the many border apparatuses that migrants and refugees face include the myriad 'cooperative' measures between European states and perceived 'transit' and/or 'origin' states- a form of externalized borderwork- that seeks to regulate the flows of migrants perceived to be heading toward Europe. Externalizing these borders has relied on a variety of policy instruments whereby the mainstreaming of migration priorities with development activities abroad is emerging as a central European policy priority. This thesis explores this trend empirically through a focused case study of the EU Emergency Trust Fund for Africa (EUTF-A) instrument to deconstruct (1) how we should understand the mainstreaming of the European migration/border enforcement agenda with European development cooperation as a strategy of border externalization, and to unpack, (2) how the developmental dimension of such initiatives facilitates related borderwork. This policy instrument is analyzed using an interdisciplinary approach with an interpretive qualitative methodology based on a document analysis and discourses analysis of key EUTF-A policy documents, as well as a critical visual analysis of its "Stories from Africa" Virtual Exhibition. Findings illustrate that the EUTF-A facilitates externalized borderwork by enabling dialogues on return/readmission and other border arrangements and by funding borderwork projects and actors on the ground. The coupling of development cooperation with migration control appears to legitimize Europe's externalized border activities as necessary and positive practices. This thesis thereby argues that the mainstreamed migration-development agenda serves to embed migration priorities into development priorities and its developmental dimension depoliticizes border externalization and the related European migration agenda. Findings contribute to a literature that has not sufficiently engaged with the different features of migration management tools, nor sufficiently engaged with the developmental nature of the border interventions themselves"--

The Long Shadow of the Border

The Long Shadow of the Border
Author: Ida Marie Savio Vammen
Publisher: Taylor & Francis
Total Pages: 194
Release: 2023-06-19
Genre: Political Science
ISBN: 1000910156

This book delves beyond the spectacular images of African migrants struggling to scale border fences or cross the Mediterranean in unseaworthy rubber dinghies by unpacking the policies and emerging practices that shape contemporary border governance in the expanding EU–African borderlands. For decades, Africa has been the scene of a wide range of European interventions aimed at restraining irregularised migration to Europe creating an accelerated moment of control and confinement. Today, the externalisation of Europe’s borders into Africa encompasses agreements on the return of migrants, securitised border operations and projects under the EU’s Emergency Trust Fund for Africa. At a time when safe and legal mobility is limited, and the human, social and political conditions of African migrants are severely challenged, this book emphasises how European efforts are both assisted but also resisted by local actors with agendas of their own. Based on ethnographic fieldwork, the different contributions vividly portray how African lives continue to be shaped by Europe’s desire to contain and govern human mobility and how dominant spatial geopolitics are contested on various levels. This book will be of particular value to students and researchers interested in African studies, International Politics, Border Governance, Anthropology, Human Geography and Global Studies. The chapters in this book were originally published as a special issue of Geopolitics.

EurAfrican Borders and Migration Management

EurAfrican Borders and Migration Management
Author: Paolo Gaibazzi
Publisher: Springer
Total Pages: 307
Release: 2016-10-25
Genre: Political Science
ISBN: 1349949728

This volume traces the African ramifications of Europe’s southern border. While the Mediterranean Sea has become the main stage for the current play and tragedy between European borders and African migrants, Europe’s southern border has also been “offshored” to Africa, mainly through cooperation agreements with countries of transit and origin. By bringing into conversation case studies from different countries and disciplines, this volume seeks to open a window on the backstage of this externalization of borders. It casts light on the sites – from consulates to open seas and deserts – in which Europe’s southern border is made and unmade as an African reality, yielding what the editors call "EurAfrican borders." It further describes the multiple actors – state agents, migrants, smugglers, activists, etc. – that variously imagine, construct, cross or contest these borders, and situates their encounters within the history of uneven exchanges between Africa and Europe.

Expanding Boundaries

Expanding Boundaries
Author: Jussi P. Laine
Publisher: Routledge
Total Pages: 394
Release: 2020-12-27
Genre: Science
ISBN: 1000318184

This book challenges the common European notions about African migration to Europe and offers a holistic understanding of the current situation in Africa. It advocates a need to rethink Africa-Europe relations and view migration and borders as a resource rather than sources of a crisis. Migrant movement from Africa is often misunderstood and misrepresented as invasion caused by displacement due to poverty, violent conflict and environmental stress. To control this movement and preserve national identities, the EU and its various member states resort to closing borders as a way of reinforcing their migration policies. This book aims to dismantle this stereotypical view of migration from Africa by sharing cutting-edge research from the leading scholars in Africa and Europe. It refutes the flawed narratives that position Africa as a threat to the European societies, their economies and security, and encourages a nuanced understanding of the root causes as well as the socioeconomic factors that guide the migrants’ decision-making. With chapters written in a concise style, this book brings together the migration and border studies in an innovative way to delve into the broader societal impacts of both. It also serves to de-silence the African voices in order to offer fresh insights on African migration – a discourse dominated hitherto by the European perspective. This book constitutes a valuable resource for research scholars and students of Border Studies, Migration Studies, Conflict and Security Studies, and Development Studies seeking specialisation in these areas. Written in an accessible style, it will also appeal to a more general public interested in gaining a fuller perspective on the African reality. Chapter 13 of this book is freely available as a downloadable Open Access PDF at http://www.taylorfrancis.com under a Creative Commons Attribution-Non Commercial-No Derivatives (CC-BY-NC-ND) 4.0 license.

Africa and Fortress Europe

Africa and Fortress Europe
Author: Belachew Gebrewold
Publisher: Routledge
Total Pages: 203
Release: 2016-03-16
Genre: Political Science
ISBN: 1317184572

The number of African migrants attempting to enter Europe has increased. Within Europe, North African migrants are being accused of increased involvement in Islamic fundamentalism and terrorist activities after attacks on Madrid and London. Such terrorist attacks have become an urgent security concern for the European Union, forcing the EU to make migration a security policy. This volume examines the extent to which the EU is threatened by patterns of African crisis, alongside Africa's peace, security and development initiatives. The contributors analyze current migration flows from Africa to Europe, and the challenges and prospects of a comprehensive EU strategy for Africa. Intended for undergraduates, graduates and lecturers, the volume is ideal for courses that discuss the impact of African political developments on international politics.

Europe's Border Crisis

Europe's Border Crisis
Author: Nick Vaughan-Williams
Publisher: Oxford University Press, USA
Total Pages: 191
Release: 2015
Genre: Political Science
ISBN: 0198747020

The European Union (EU) Commission champions a 'migrant-centred' approach to border security and 'irregular' migration management: it claims not only to observe human rights, but also to use surveillance to enhance the humanitarian protection of 'endangered' lives on land and at sea. Yet research presented by Non-Governmental Organizations and 'irregular' migrants' own testimonies reveal systemic border violence, dehumanization in spaces of detention, and exposure to death via abandonment in hostile environments. This book turns to conceptual resources found in biopolitical theory in order to move diagnoses of Europe's border crisis beyond that of a 'gap' between the policy 'rhetoric' of humanitarianism and the 'reality' of 'irregular' migrants' embodied experiences. It argues that both 'positive' and 'negative' dimensions of EU border security are symptomatic of tensions within biopolitical techniques of government and what Roberto Esposito refers to as the paradigm of immunization. While bordering practices are designed to play a defensive role they contain the potential for excessive and often lethal security mechanisms that end up threatening the very values and lives they purport to protect. Each chapter draws on a different biopolitical key to identify and interrogate diverse technologies of power at a range of border sites. Must border security always result in dehumanization and death? Are humanitarian discourses sufficient for critiquing contemporary forms of border violence? Is a more affirmative approach to border politics possible? 'Europe's border crisis' addresses these pressing questions and advances new research agendas for critical border and migration studies beyond existing debates about 'control' versus 'escape'.

The EU Border Management Strategy

The EU Border Management Strategy
Author: Sergio Carrera
Publisher: CEPS
Total Pages: 35
Release: 2008
Genre: Boundaries
ISBN: 9290797029

The EU is developing a border management strategy aiming at an quot;integrated and global responsequot; to the challenges posed by the phenomenon of irregular immigration through the common external borders. quot;The Southern maritime bordersquot; constitute one of the main targets addressed by this strategy. On November 2006, the European Commission published a communication calling for the reinforced management of the EU's Southern maritime borders and for the maximization of the capacities of the European Agency for the Management of Operational Cooperation at the External Borders of the Member States of the European Union - FRONTEX. This paper provides some reflections about these current policy approaches by looking at the nature, scope and practical implications of the implementation of the Integrated Border Management strategy and its relationship with a common EU immigration policy. After assessing the latest policy developments in these areas, we raise a number of questions about some of the functions and capacities carried out by FRONTEX, and present a series of vulnerabilities characterizing the joint operations coordinated by this Community body taking the example of the operations HERA I, II and III in the Canary Islands (Spain).

The EU's Shifting Borders

The EU's Shifting Borders
Author: Klaus Bachmann
Publisher: Routledge
Total Pages: 293
Release: 2012-03-12
Genre: Political Science
ISBN: 113657526X

The EU’s internal borders have become mostly invisible. Today, external borders are at the centre of controversy about an alleged 'fortress Europe'. Using different theoretical and methodological perspectives this book examines the challenges facing the EU’s external borders, including Neighborhood Policy, migration issues and the diffusion of norms and values to other countries. Divided into two parts, the book first presents different theoretical approaches and empirical studies of the EU’s external borders, mobility and security issues. It is an invaluable guide to border research within a framework of European Integration and Globalization Studies. The second part of this volume focuses on the analyses of the EU’s Neighbourhood Policy, the approach to Eastern Europe and EU energy policy. Expert contributors collaborate to explore debates about migration, the EU as a normative, 'civil' power, energy security and the securitization of borders. Highly relevant and insightful, the text provides a timely assessment of EU borders in an increasingly globalized and integrated European neighbourhood. The EU's Shifting Borders will be of interest to students and scholars of European Union Politics and International Relations.

Worlds Apart?

Worlds Apart?
Author: Adeoye O. Akinola
Publisher: Taylor & Francis
Total Pages: 362
Release: 2024-10-04
Genre: Social Science
ISBN: 1040144551

This book explores the crucial political and diplomatic issue of migration, which over the past decade, has become a central theme in relations between Africa and Europe. It discusses the diverse perspectives of African and European actors on migration and presents a more just and sustainable migration governance agenda, against the backdrop of the more detailed reflections on the key policy priorities, drivers, regional dynamics, and actors influencing African–EU migration. By providing an insight into the complexities and challenges of Africa–Europe relations with regard to migration governance, this book aims to generate an understanding about the disparities within this policy field to work towards more common ground and long-term policy solutions. Print edition not for sale in Sub Saharan Africa