Essays on Industrial Organization and Finance

Essays on Industrial Organization and Finance
Author: Menghan Xu
Publisher:
Total Pages: 117
Release: 2016
Genre:
ISBN:

The dissertation consists of three essays on industrial organization with a particular focus on the structures of financial markets. The first chapter theoretically studies how search friction affects competition and resource allocation in crowdfunding loan markets, which are described using a many-to-one matching framework. Namely, competitive fundraisers must accumulate multiple investors to complete a transaction. I develop a dynamic matching model with a fixed sample search, a la Burdett and Judd (1983), in which fundraisers compete in interest rates while investors look for good investment targets. I highlight two important economic forces in the model. First, investors can only observe a limited number of quotes. Second, a surplus cannot be created until a fundraiser attracts contributions from enough investors. I show that in the presence of search friction, fundraisers implement mixed strategies to set interest rates in a unique stationary equilibrium, which results in rate dispersion even if the goods are homogeneous. Regarding resource allocation, I show that in the many-to-one market, rate dispersion creates an endogenous coordination mechanism among anonymous and independent investors, thereby making it easy for them to concentrate their investments. In other words, search friction improves allocation efficiency in a crowdfunding market compared with its perfect competition counterpart. Based on the theoretical framework constructed in the first chapter, the second chapter empirically studies the market structure of the crowdfunding market. I construct a novel data set based on a large panel of fundraisers' behaviors. Using reduced form analysis, I find evidence of persistent rate dispersion and funding mismatches, which are consistent with the theoretical predictions of the search model. I also show that the model is identifiable and can be estimated using a non-parametric approach, which allows me to measure the allocation efficiency. Regarding methodology, I demonstrate that it is sufficient to use projects' ranks to recover search friction primitives, which reduces the computational burden and increases the precision. The third chapter studies how the combination of adverse selection and moral hazard affects the design of financial contracts. Specifically, the chapter studies an optimal mechanism design problem,a la Mussa and Rosen (1978), in the presence of limited enforcement. In the study, the bank (principal) designs loan contracts to screen firms (agents) with unobserved productivities. Meanwhile, the bank cannot prevent the firm from consuming acquired funds without producing anything. The impediment of forming contracts creates an endogenous outside option for all borrowers. I show that in the optimal mechanism, loan sizes for higher types are decreased by ironing, i.e., by pooling on the top. In addition, the lower types produce at the second-best level. Moreover, I show that firms' participation is independent of the enforcement level.

Three Essays on Financial Markets

Three Essays on Financial Markets
Author: Lu Zhang
Publisher:
Total Pages: 137
Release: 2015
Genre: Depressions
ISBN:

This thesis consists of three essays. The first essay studies the ability of stock return idiosyncrasy to predict future economic conditions over time. The second essay investigates the technological innovation and creative destruction during the 1920s and the 1930s, one of the most innovative periods in the 20th century. The third essay tests the performance of an investment strategy using information about past market-wide comovement. Stock return idiosyncrasy, defined as the ratio of firm-specific to systematic risk in individual stock returns, contains information about future growth rate in real GDP, industrial production, real fixed assets investment, and unemployment. Forecasts are generally significant one-quarter-ahead, particularly after World War II. These effects persist after controlling for other potential leading economic indicators, both in-sample and out-of-sample. These findings are consistent with information generating firms, presumably uniquely well-informed about economic conditions because their core business is information, adjusting their information production before downturns. The second essay studies the process of creative destruction during the technological revolution in the 1920s and 1930s. Intensified creative destruction magnifies the performance gap between winner and loser firms, and thus elevates firm-specific stock return variation. We find high firm-specific return variation in innovative industries and firms during the 1920s boom and the subsequent depression. We also find some evidence of elevated firm-specific return variation in manufacturing sectors with higher labor productivity, more research staff and more extensive electrification. In the third essay, we define the directional market-wide comovement measure as the proportion of stocks moving up together. Positing that high comovement reflects large fund inflows, we devise an investment strategy of entering the market whenever positive directional market-wide comovement passes a certain threshold. Specifically, this comovement-based investment strategy holds the market index when the market-wide upward comovement in the prior one to four weeks is above the fourth decile of the historical comovement distribution, and invests in the risk-free asset otherwise. During the sample period of 1954 to 2014, this strategy outperforms the NYSE value-weighted market index by 6.42% per year. Out of sample tests using NASDAQ stocks and TSE stocks validate the strategy. Our findings suggest that marketwide upward comovement identifies periods of market run-ups, when unsophisticated investor buying is apt to be driven by herding or information cascades.

Essays on Industrial Organization and Financial Economics

Essays on Industrial Organization and Financial Economics
Author: Xiaoye (Phoebe) Tian
Publisher:
Total Pages: 182
Release: 2021
Genre:
ISBN:

This dissertation explores how imperfections in financial markets affect decisions made by market participants and subsequent market outcomes. The three chapters in this dissertation focus on three different financial markets: corporate lending market for small firms in China, refinance market for residential mortgage in US and retail investment product market in China. The first chapter studies inefficiencies arising from the lack of long-term contracting between borrower (firm) and lender (bank). I draw on a proprietary data from a Chinese bank, which only offers one-year term loans for small firms. How, and to what extent can default risk be reduced if they were able to enter long-term contract? I develop a dynamic model of business lending to analyze borrower's default incentives in an environment with imperfect information and learning. Estimation of the structural model implies that over seventy percent of observed defaults are strategic borrower defaults. In the counterfactual model, banks are able to offer long-term contingent contract which involves a schedule of future lending terms that can vary with time and firm's financial status. I find that optimal long-term contract has two main benefits: First, by frontloading prices, it alleviates agency frictions and disincentivizes willful defaults. Second, by cross-subsidization, it provides insurance for firms against negative shocks. As a result, with long-term contracting 17% fewer firms default, and total firm outputs expand by 2.6%. The second chapter (joint with Chen Zheng) studies the unintended consequences arising from program design, and how it augments the market power of incumbent lenders, in the context of a federal program called Home Affordable Refinance Program. We build a dynamic discrete choice model of refinance decision where the payoff is generated from a search and negotiation process. We estimate the model using data on program participation and pricing decision. The estimation exploits a significant change to the program design that gives exogenous variation in the competitive advantage of incumbent lenders under the program. In a counterfactual where the advantage granted by program design is shut down, we find that it leads to an average welfare improvement of 4,977. The insight from this study could apply to other policies whose implementation depends on intermediaries with incumbency advantage with respect to targeted agents. In the third chapter, I develop an empirical structural model of the wealth management sector in China in order to analyze the welfare impact of the proposed regulation aimed at ending the prevalence of the implicit guarantee in this industry. The implicit guarantee means the bank implicitly promises the returns on wealth management products to investors, and investors choose from differentiated wealth management products based on characteristics including guaranteed returns. In the counterfactual post-regulation scenario, the bank does not guarantee returns, and it only serves as an intermediary charging a constant fee, shifting the underlying risk of investment to investors. The change of consumer welfare hinges on two forces-the adjustment of the bank's markups and investor's disutility of risk. Empirical findings suggest that the markup decreases moderately, but not enough to completely compensate for investor's aversion of risk, so consumer surplus drops slightly as a result of the regulation.

Three Essays on Financial Markets

Three Essays on Financial Markets
Author: Andrey G. Zagorchev
Publisher:
Total Pages: 141
Release: 2010
Genre:
ISBN: 9781124193748

The third essay examines the impact of government ownership and financial markets on corporate governance using 1327 firms from fourteen EU countries in the period 2003 to 2008. The results show that aggregate government ownership measured through privatization and financial markets lead to improvements in the corporate governance practices of firms.