The Impact of Timed Versus Untimed Standardized Tests on Reading Scores of Third-grade Students in Title I Schools

The Impact of Timed Versus Untimed Standardized Tests on Reading Scores of Third-grade Students in Title I Schools
Author: Ruth Elizabeth Haniff
Publisher:
Total Pages: 148
Release: 2012
Genre: Educational tests and measurements
ISBN:

The purpose of this study was to investigate the extent to which the performance of Title I third grade students in a central Florida School District differed on tests administered under timed and untimed conditions. Further examined was the literature on reasons for the achievement gap which centered around seven different themes: (a) standardized testing, (b) achievement gap data and identified factors (c) deficit theory, (d) cultural mismatch theory, (e) extended time accommodations, (f) test anxiety and stress, and (g) timed versus untimed tests. Six Title I schools participated in this study by assigning 194 students to take the 2006 Released FCAT Reading Test under either timed or untimed conditions. Although there were no interactions between the covariates and testing conditions, those who were in the free or reduced lunch program or were in exceptional education programs had lower FCAT scores than those who were not. However, when school was included as a moderator, there was a statistically significant interaction between testing conditions and schools on FCAT scores indicating that the relationship between testing conditions and FCAT scores varied for each individual school. A factorial ANCOVA was conducted, and it was found that the mean differences between students who took the timed and untimed 2006 FCAT Reading Test varied from school to school after accounting for the covariates. For two schools, those students who took the untimed tests scored higher than those who took the timed tests. In contrast, those students who took the untimed tests scored lower than those students who took the timed test for one of the schools. There was no statistically significant difference for three of the schools. A factorial MANCOVA was used to compare reading performance on the 2006 Reading FCAT between the timed and untimed groups on domain specific tests. The relationship between testing condition and FCAT scores for each domain specific test varied depending on the individual school. Therefore, it could not be concluded from these analyses that testing conditions would consistently result in increases or decreases of student performance on standardized domain specific tests.

Effects of Rate and Accuracy of Test Responses, Removal of Test Time-limits and Teacher Expectancies on Achievement Test Scores of Disadvantaged Third Grade Students in Denver

Effects of Rate and Accuracy of Test Responses, Removal of Test Time-limits and Teacher Expectancies on Achievement Test Scores of Disadvantaged Third Grade Students in Denver
Author: William Eugene Lewis
Publisher:
Total Pages: 208
Release: 1973
Genre: Educational tests and measurements
ISBN:

The purpose of this study was to investigate one individual difference, i.e., rate of response, and the effect on student performance when teachers recognize this difference. Using disadvantaged third grade students as subjects, three null hypotheses were formulated as follows: 1. Slow responding accurate students' (Group LH) scores will show no significant difference over rapidly responding inaccurate students' (Group HL) scores on the Metropolitan Achievement Test when test time-limits are extended. 2. There will be no significant difference on Metropolitan Achievement Test mean scores between students allowed longer daily work-limits during the school year and those students using regular daily work-limits during the school year. 3. There will be no significant difference on Metropolitan Achievement Test mean scores between students allowed longer daily work-limits during the school year and those students using regular daily work-limits during the school year when test time-limits are extended. The t-test was applied for hypothesis number one and the analysis of variance F-statistic was used for both hypotheses two and three. Findings: The findings of this study indicated the acceptance of null hypothesis number two and the rejection of null hypotheses numbers one and three. Rejection of hypothesis number one lends support to the belief that some children exist that are slow responding but not mentally low. Hypothesis number three lends support to the belief that time to work accurately is an important factor for some children and that test time-limits may impose a penalty on these children rather than measuring accurately the child's abilities or skills. Further Findings: These disadvantaged third graders with an overall mean I.Q. of 97 managed to respond to practically every question on six subtests and about half of the students finished the seventh subtest easily within the standard time limit. On one mathematics subtest, Mathematics Computation, only four students out of 230 did not complete the answer sheet within the standard test time-limit. Participating teachers remarked that some children were 'finished" with the answer sheet before all of the test booklets had been distributed and that most of the children work for awhile, become totally frustrated, and then arbitrarily fill in the remaining answers. Recommendations: In view of the findings of this study, the writer offers the following recommendations. 1. To testing departments of public schools and to test publishers: Standardized tests need to be redesigned to provide a strong incentive to the test taker to "try" each question, whether the incentive be a reward, recognition, or just fun to do. At the present time and using present standardized tests, these disadvantaged children really have no reason to do anything but use the answer sheet for drawing geometric designs. 2. To school boards and state legislators: Strong objections should be raised in the use of present standardized achievement tests in fulfilling accountability law requirements. 3. To schools of education and students involved in research: With some gain apparent with informed groups (students given longer work-limits and aware teachers) in this study and with the successful research cited in Chapter II, further study into teacher expectancies with disadvantaged children is vital. 4. To school administrators and teachers: Revise testing procedures to improve teaching-testing feedback for children, This could be accomplished through in-service education of administrators and teachers.

Reading First and Its Effects on Third Grade CRCT Reading Scores

Reading First and Its Effects on Third Grade CRCT Reading Scores
Author: Dorothy Young Crimes
Publisher:
Total Pages: 80
Release: 2009
Genre: Criterion-referenced tests
ISBN:

This quantitative research study evaluated CRCT reading achievement of students in third grade who received reading instruction with the guidance of the Reading First Program and students who received reading instruction without the guidance of the Reading First Program. The study included CRCT reading scores for third grade students in the spring of 2004, at the time the Quality Core Curriculum (QCC) Standards were used. By the spring of 2008, Georgia was following the Georgia Performance Standards (GPS). The third grade students tested in spring 2004 did not receive reading instruction with the guidance of the First program. The students who were tested in spring 2008 received reading instruction with the guidance of the Reading First Program from kindergarten through third grade. The data was collected from a small, rural public school in southwest Georgia. To analyze the data, a chi square statistic was calculated across the categories “did not meet” standards, “met” standards and “exceeded” standards. The researcher examined 79 third grade CRCT reading subtest scores. The researcher concluded that there is no statistical difference in CRCT reading scores for the two groups researched.

The Effect of Ready for Success, a Counselor-led Intervention Program, on Reading Scores of Hispanic and African American 3rd Grade Students in Title One Elementary Schools

The Effect of Ready for Success, a Counselor-led Intervention Program, on Reading Scores of Hispanic and African American 3rd Grade Students in Title One Elementary Schools
Author: Sherron N. Brown
Publisher:
Total Pages: 142
Release: 2014
Genre: Academic achievement
ISBN:

This study focused on evaluating the impact of a school counselor-led program, Ready for Success (RFS), on the academic achievement of third grade students. The research questions that were investigated in the study were: (a) Does participation in the Ready for Success Program, a counselor-led classroom intervention, increase reading scores among 3rd grade African American, Hispanic, and White students as measured by the FCAT third grade reading test? and (b) Does participation in the Ready for Success Program, a counselor-led classroom intervention, increase reading scores among third grade African American, Hispanic, and White students as measured by the SSSDT reading test? The significance of the study lies in its focus on the need for more outcome research linking school counselor-led interventions to student achievement. The importance of counselor-led research based interventions in positively affecting student achievement addresses a national mandate delineated by the No Child Left Behind Act of 2001, which calls for evidence-based interventions in education. The population for this study included male and female, third grade, general education students from diverse backgrounds, from one large school district located in south Florida, herein referred to as Pineapple State School District. A standardized objective statewide assessment instrument, the Florida Comprehensive Assessment Test (FCAT) and the school district generated standardized test, Sunshine State Standards Diagnostics Test (SSSDT), were used to measure academic achievement. Analysis of the results in this study was done using an analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) with Pretest scores on the SSSDT 3rd grade reading (2010-2011) as covariates on the dependent variables to account for differences at pretest.

The Effects of School-based Tutoring on the Reading Scores of Third Grade Students

The Effects of School-based Tutoring on the Reading Scores of Third Grade Students
Author: Jenny Elisa Washington
Publisher:
Total Pages: 144
Release: 2018
Genre: Reading (Elementary)
ISBN:

Reading below grade level in the third grade is a serious issue that too many students are facing. If struggling readers do not improve their reading skills prior to entering the fourth grade, they risk academic failure and limited success in the future. It is important, therefore, to get students who are not reading on grade level back on track as soon as possible. The purpose of this quantitative causal-comparative study was to determine the effectiveness of tutoring for improving the reading skills of third graders. A sample population of 2,565 third graders from 43 Title I elementary schools in a large rural school district in Southeastern North Carolina participated in this study. Deindentified data for the participants were collected from the school district’s Associate Superintendent for Evaluation and Testing. The descriptive statistics was computed for each tutoring group using SPSS. This causal-comparative research design also used a two-way ANOVA in SPSS to examine the reading achievement scores on the North Carolina READY English Language Arts/Reading Assessment for the sample population for the beginning and end of the 2016-2017 school year. All three of the tutoring comparison groups of students served as treatment groups and control groups for the others. The researcher examined the following research question: Is there a difference among the reading achievement scores of male and female third grade students who participate in one-to-one tutoring, small-group tutoring, or large-group tutoring? It was determined that there was a statistically significant difference in the mean reading scores between the third graders participating in one-to-one, small-group and large-group tutoring. There was not a statistically significant difference in mean reading scores between females and males. There was a statistically significant interaction between gender and tutoring type for the difference in the BOG and EOG Reading Scores. This study was important because the results could provide educators with information for improving students’ reading skills through tutoring. Recommendations for further research based on the results of this study could include: to find out if an achievement gap remains after tracking the literacy competency levels of the participants in this study as they matriculate through school , conducting a mixed-methods study to examine the literacy skills that are being taught by third grade teachers whose students perform at or above grade level on the North Carolina READY English Language Arts/Reading Assessments for grade 3 (End-of-Grade 3 (EOG 3)) versus third grade teachers whose students do not perform at or above grade level, conducting a mixed-methods study to examine the literacy skills that are being taught by second grade teachers in the district whose previous students perform at or above grade level on the North Carolina READY English Language Arts/Reading Assessments for grade 3 (Beginning-of-Grade 3 (BOG 3)) versus second grade teachers whose students do not perform at or above grade level, and extend this study to include other school districts to determine if the results would be similar.

A Causal-comparative Analysis of the Effect of Reading Instruction on the Reading Achievement of Third-grade Students in Title I Elementary Schools

A Causal-comparative Analysis of the Effect of Reading Instruction on the Reading Achievement of Third-grade Students in Title I Elementary Schools
Author: Hamilton Smith
Publisher:
Total Pages: 134
Release: 2018
Genre: Reading (Elementary)
ISBN:

Title I, Part A (Title I) of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA) allocates federal government funds to schools serving low-income families. Title I schools receive additional financial support to combat the impact of poverty on students’ elementary and secondary education. This quantitative causal-comparative study examined the effect of reading instruction on third-grade students’ reading achievement score. The study included Title I elementary schools (n=4) within an urban school district in the Southeastern region of the United States. Participants included a convenience sampling of third-grade students (N=340). The researcher collected anonymous archived reading achievement scores from the Renaissance Star 360® reading assessment administered by Independent School District (pseudonym). Pre-test and post-test reading achievement scores were analyzed using an analysis of covariance (ANCOVA). The results of the ANCOVA indicated a statistically significant difference between the reading achievement scores of third-grade students who participated in guided reading instruction and third-grade students who participated in whole-group reading instruction while controlling for pre-test reading achievement scores. The findings rejected the null hypothesis. Implications of the findings were examined alongside recommendations for future research.

Effects of Untimed Versus Timed Practice on Oral Reading Fluency and Recall of Second and Third Graders with Mild Disabilities and Autism

Effects of Untimed Versus Timed Practice on Oral Reading Fluency and Recall of Second and Third Graders with Mild Disabilities and Autism
Author: Kathleen M. Heron
Publisher:
Total Pages: 270
Release: 2006
Genre: Developmentally disabled children
ISBN:

Abstract: The purpose of this study was to determine the effects of untimed versus timed practice on the oral reading fluency and recall of second and third graders with mild disabilities and autism. Four students enrolled in a multiage, inclusive classroom served as the participants. The intervention was conducted principally in the participants' classroom. In both conditions, the participants practiced reading a passage for three minutes, and data were collected on the number of words read correctly and incorrectly during a fourth timing. The data show a functional relation between untimed and timed practice on the number of words read correctly per minute, however, the data for the number of words read incorrectly was less evident. These findings suggest that timed practice is an effective strategy for improving oral reading fluency and recall. Further research is necessary to refine these procedures and determine the effects of these interventions on other populations.

The Effects of the Reading Academy Intensive Support Education (RAISE) Summer School Program on Students' Third Grade Reading Guarantee (TGRG) Assessment Scores

The Effects of the Reading Academy Intensive Support Education (RAISE) Summer School Program on Students' Third Grade Reading Guarantee (TGRG) Assessment Scores
Author: Susan M. Breymaier
Publisher:
Total Pages: 297
Release: 2018
Genre: Educational tests and measurements
ISBN:

Providing struggling readers with research-based interventions, outside of the regular school day, is advantageous in giving students the time they need to remediate the basic foundational skills necessary for proficient reading. Therefore, to increase learning time and provide reading intervention for students who have not mastered basic foundational reading skills, Toledo Public Schools delivers an intense, research-based summer reading intervention program (RAISE) to third grade students who have not met the Third Grade Reading Guarantee (TGRG) by the end of the students' third grade school year. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the reading achievement of students participating in this intensive, summer reading program. Quantitative analysis is the methodology that was used in this study to determine if statistical differences existed on reading assessment scores for students who qualified for the RAISE summer program. The results of the SPSS analysis indicated that students who attended the RAISE summer program earned a slightly higher mean score, the following school year, on their spring state reading assessment than students who were identified for the RAISE program and did not participate. However, the difference was not statistically significant. The results further indicated that even though there was sufficient evidence that there may be a difference for the same student before and after participation in the RAISE summer program, for a majority of the years analyzed, the t-test mean scores were, in most cases, not high enough to meet the TGRG requirements. The results also indicated that while students who attended the RAISE summer program made mean score gains, there was no significant differences between students who attended more than 80 percent of the time and students who attended less than 80 percent of the time. Implications of this study indicate that increased learning time outside the regular school day does benefit students, however, this increased learning time needs to occur before third grade. Recommendations were made for both practice and future research, including recommendations for early childhood increased learning time programs.