The Impact of Government Support on the Performance of Indonesia's State-owned Enterprises

The Impact of Government Support on the Performance of Indonesia's State-owned Enterprises
Author: Hendro Nugroho
Publisher:
Total Pages:
Release: 2019
Genre:
ISBN:

This study analyzes the impact of government support on the financial performance of Indonesia's state-owned enterprises (SOEs). I employ the ordinary least square (OLS) method with firm and year fixed effects in addition to clustered standard errors. The findings show that government support for SOEs does not have a significant effect on their financial performance. This study finds that the government should examine its investment policy to support SOEs and consider designing a proper government support policy to generate higher SOE financial performance.

Unlocking the Economic and Social Value of Indonesia’s State-Owned Enterprises

Unlocking the Economic and Social Value of Indonesia’s State-Owned Enterprises
Author: Asian Development Bank
Publisher: Asian Development Bank
Total Pages: 116
Release: 2022-12-01
Genre: Political Science
ISBN: 9292698044

This report provides an analysis of Indonesia's state-owned enterprises (SOEs), explores their prominent economic and social role, and explains how further reforms can unlock their commercial and developmental potential. Acting as a diagnostic to help inform the government's SOE reform agenda, the report emphasizes the need to strengthen governance and refine incentives. Explaining how SOEs have the potential to help solve core challenges around building infrastructure or tackling climate change, it shows how strengthening SOEs through targeted measures can ensure they better support Indonesia's pandemic recovery and drive stronger economic growth.

Are State-owned Enterprises Successful Vehicles for Attaining Their Government Objectives?

Are State-owned Enterprises Successful Vehicles for Attaining Their Government Objectives?
Author: Andriati Fitriningrum
Publisher:
Total Pages: 0
Release: 2015
Genre:
ISBN:

The purpose of this study is to examine whether Indonesian Badan Usaha Milik Negara (BUMN) or State-Owned Enterprises (SOE) are successful vehicles for attaining government socio-economic and financial objectives. The motives for undertaking this study arise from the importance of SOEs in national economic and socio-political roles in developing countries like Indonesia, even after their privatisation. This thesis identifies the implications of policy changes for the Indonesian government's objectives for SOEs. First, an historical examination of changes in the institutional and economic environment in Indonesia (Chapters 6-8) identifies substantial impacts on the evolution of the structure of SOEs and the government's objectives for SOEs. The first stage of this analysis reveals that the "see-sawing" of economic policy between centralisation and market orientation led to changes in the structure and objectives of the SOEs. Initially, the state enterprises established during the Indonesianisation period (1945-1958) had multiple socio-political objectives with little concern for economic of financial objectives. The reforms during the nationalisation period (1958-1966) included the restructuring of previously nationalised companies as Perusahaan Negara, and the introduction of profit objectives for some Perusahaan Negara. In the corporatisation period (1966 - present), the Perusahaan Negara were reformed and divided into three types of entities: Persero, Perum and Perjan. The Persero are incorporated entities that have both commercial and social welfare objectives. The Perum are incorporated entities that are not commercial but have profit objectives and social welfare objectives. The Perjan are not incorporated (remaining as state agencies) and have only social welfare objectives. Perusahaan Negara poor performance and fiscal problem in the early 1980s encouraged the reform of Perusahaan Negara structure as Badan Usaha Milik Negara (BUMN/SOE). The introduction of partial-privatisation policy in 1991 encouraged profit and efficiency objectives for SOEs that could potentially be privatised. The implementation of fast track privatisation in 2002 caused significant changes in the SOEs structure and objectives. The government encouraged all SOEs to implement corporatisation principles in which emphasise financial objectives such as profit and efficiency. The government eliminated the Perjan structure, which it considered to have become a barrier to the implementation of full corporatisation and fast track privatisation. In practice, social welfare and non-economic remained a major Badan Usaha Milik Negara (BUMN/SOE) objectives. From the late 1990s, external pressure from international financial institutions was a significant factor in the government's efforts to privatise the SOEs. In the second part of the historical analysis in this thesis, privatisation is shown to be a major influence on policies and SOEs' objectives. Privatisation represents a fundamental change in the government-stated objectives and policies for SOEs, and included the introduction of an 'open market' policy, development of domestic capital market activities, and full implementation of corporatisation principles. However, privatisation in Indonesia is constrained by the 1945 Constitution of Indonesia regarding the control policy, which leads to different categories of SOEs with respect to privatisation and the importance of economic or financial objectives. There are now three categories of SOEs: those that have been identified as not available for privatisation, those that can be privatised but are still fully owned by the government, and those that have been privatised. As a consequence of the constitutional barrier and political interests, most privatisations of SOEs were partial. The continuation of government control over these partially privatised SOEs increased the potential for conflict between the greater emphasis on financial objectives arising from private investors and the government's continuing socio-political objectives for these SOEs. This is emphasised in analysis of the most intensive period of privatisation (2002-2004). An examination of SOEs objectives in practices shows that privatisation policy makes some differences in regards to the government objectives and treatment for the SOEs. In addition to three different categories of SOEs, privatisation policy encourages the importance of profit and efficiency objectives which apply to all SOEs. In contrast, the content analysis (Chapters 8-9) reveals that the government inconsistency in implementing the new profit and efficiency policies and caused the absence of profit and efficiency objectives as part of the government objectives for numbers of SOE. The potential conflicting objectives arises between the government and SOEs when the SOEs have to deal with the pressure and changes from their markets. Building on the conceptually conflicting objectives identified in the historical analysis, the thesis then empirically assesses the extent of apparent conflicts within government objectives, and between the government's and SOEs objectives, and the implication on the performance of SOEs with respect to government objectives. First, the extent of apparent conflicts emerges as the government introduces profit and efficiency objectives, while in practice; the government has never made any changes in the government-stated objectives for each individual SOE. Second, the company constitution and management objectives are more likely to make changes of the objectives in order to accommodate the changes in their market. Next, identifies the objectives for which objective (proxy) performance measures are available: these are financial performance and financial performance that represent the social welfare. Using these measures, the different types of performance of SOE's are regressed against indicators of government-stated objectives for SOEs, whether the objectives make a different or affect the SOEs performance. Examination of the relations between the government-stated objectives and SOEs financial performance shows some weak negative relations between the government-stated objectives and SOEs financial performance. The reliance of many Indonesian SOEs on non-core business income (such as subsidies and asset disposals) and external financial support (such as soft loans from government-controlled lenders) indicates the inconsistency between the SOEs financial objectives and achieving the government's social welfare and non-economic objectives.

Reforms, Opportunities, and Challenges for State-Owned Enterprises

Reforms, Opportunities, and Challenges for State-Owned Enterprises
Author: Edimon Ginting
Publisher: Asian Development Bank
Total Pages: 355
Release: 2020-07-01
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 9292622838

State-owned enterprises (SOEs) play significant roles in developing economies in Asia and SOE performance remains crucial for economy-wide productivity and growth. This book looks at SOEs in Azerbaijan, Indonesia, Kazakhstan, the People's Republic of China, and Viet Nam, which together present a panoramic view of SOEs in the region. It also presents insights from the Republic of Korea on the evolving role of the public sector in various stages of development. It explores corporate governance challenges and how governments could reform SOEs to make them efficient drivers of the long-term productivity-induced growth essential to Asia's transition to high-income status.

Performance of State Owned Enterprises in Indonesia and Malaysia

Performance of State Owned Enterprises in Indonesia and Malaysia
Author: Citra Sukmadilaga
Publisher:
Total Pages: 9
Release: 2017
Genre:
ISBN:

Objective - The purpose of this research is to measure performance of State-owned Enterprises that listed in Bursa Malaysia and Indonesian Stock Exchange.Methodology/Technique - The economic performance will be measured by DEA. This study was employed technical efficiency and Malmquist Productivity Index. Period of this study was conduct from 1992 to 2007, consist of three periods: a) Pre Crisis, b) Crisis, and c) Post Crisis.Findings - For Indonesia's SOEs, the conclusion over the periods of study that the technical efficiency of SOEs improved, especially in period of Crisis, when government injected direct subsidies in order to enable SOEs maintain their performances. Meanwhile, the result for Malaysia's SOEs sample demonstrates that over the periods of study, technical efficiency of SOEs was also improved. The improvement from Pre-crisis to Crisis period was not only due to some enterprises having early recovery compared to others but also government supported SOEs during crisis, by getting lower investment and export financing cost and purchasing and sales preference.Novelty - There is lack of studies on State-owned Enterprises productivity in this region, so this study can fill this research gap and provide a useful reference to policy makers and users.Type of Paper: Empirical.

Governance and State-Owned Enterprises: How Costly is Corruption?

Governance and State-Owned Enterprises: How Costly is Corruption?
Author: Ms.Anja Baum
Publisher: International Monetary Fund
Total Pages: 43
Release: 2019-11-22
Genre: Social Science
ISBN: 1513522221

State-owned enterprises (SOEs) are present in key sectors of the economies around the world. While they can provide an important public service, there is widespread concern that their activities are negatively affected by corruption. However, there is limited cross-country analysis on the costs of corruption for SOEs. We present new evidence on how corruption affects the performance of SOEs using firm level data across a large number of countries. One striking result is that SOEs perform as well as private firms in core sectors when corruption is low. Taking advantage of a novel database reforms, we also show that SOE governance reforms can generate significant performance gains.

State-Owned Enterprises in Middle East, North Africa, and Central Asia: Size, Costs, and Challenges

State-Owned Enterprises in Middle East, North Africa, and Central Asia: Size, Costs, and Challenges
Author: Mr. Ernesto Ramirez Rigo
Publisher: International Monetary Fund
Total Pages: 153
Release: 2021-09-20
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 1513594087

Prior to the COVID-19 shock, the key challenge facing policymakers in the Middle East, North Africa, and Central Asia region was how to generate strong, sustainable, job-rich, inclusive growth. Post-COVID-19, this challenge has only grown given the additional reduction in fiscal space due to the crisis and the increased need to support the recovery. The sizable state-owned enterprise (SOE) footprint in the region, together with its cost to the government, call for revisiting the SOE sector to help open fiscal space and look for growth opportunities.

Business and Social Efficiency of the Indonesian State-owned Enterprises

Business and Social Efficiency of the Indonesian State-owned Enterprises
Author: Irwanda Wisnu Wardhana
Publisher:
Total Pages: 102
Release: 2016
Genre: Data envelopment analysis
ISBN:

This research aims to examine the relationships of government ownership, social efficiency and business efficiency of the Indonesian State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs). It employs two research hypotheses: firms with higher government ownership are more likely to have higher social efficiency and firms with higher social efficiency are more likely to have lower business efficiency. The SOEs are divided into three categories based on types of government ownership: Perum, Persero, and Listed Persero. The dataset consists of 126 SOEs operating in six industrial sectors in a ten years observation period (2004-2013). The study employs data envelopment analysis (DEA), analysis of variance, and panel regressions. The Social Efficiency model focuses on job creation ability over revenue, whereas the Business Efficiency model centers on revenue generation capacity over total assets. We reject the first hypothesis that government ownership has influence on both social and business efficiency; however, we fail to reject the second hypothesis that social efficiency has significant and negative relationships with business efficiency. The research provides evidence that social efficiency measurement will be useful in improving the performance of SOEs that have two mission objectives: social and business.