The Argentine Pension Reform and Its Relevance for Eastern Europe

The Argentine Pension Reform and Its Relevance for Eastern Europe
Author: Dimitri Vittas
Publisher:
Total Pages: 0
Release: 2010
Genre:
ISBN:

Argentina's experience with pension reform offers important lessons for Eastern Europe. A balanced reform is politically feasible, while prolonged delays in implementing pension reform can lead to the collapse of traditional, unfunded pension systems. Argentina reformed its pension system in 1994, when it created an integrated, multipillar public-private pension system. Its old system had suffered from a vicious circle of unrealistic promises, high payroll taxes, widespread evasion, and growing deficits. But the reform program, enacted through the democratic process, suffered from many weaknesses, the most important of which were the continuing wage indexation of pensions and the retention of a public, unfunded, defined benefit component in the second pillar. The Argentine authorities were forced to take corrective measures, first by abolishing indexation with the passage of the Pension Solidarity Law in March 1995 and then by integrating provincial pension schemes into the national system. Vittas argues that Argentina has undertaken not one but three major reforms of its pension system since 1993. One lesson of the Argentine experience is that pension reform is diluted as a result of democratic debate. This is less crucial than it appears, because reforming governments can rectify any major shortcomings through subsequent reforms. But it is important that the reform program be basically sound and that it move in the right direction. Vittas compares the new Argentine system with the systems of Chile and Switzerland. He finds that the main difference between the Argentine and Chilean systems lies in the higher levels of targeted pensions and targeted redistribution in Argentina. This is a political and social choice, but it implies a higher financial cost and thus higher contribution rates. The private component of the second pillar shares most of the strengths and weaknesses of the Chilean model, including high marketing and operating costs. The comparison with the Swiss system shows that Argentina's first pillar is less well designed than Switzerland's. But the funded component of its second pillar is more transparent and potentially more efficient than the Swiss funded pillar. Although it has much higher operating costs, it has achieved much higher investment returns. The relevance of the Argentine pension reform for Eastern Europe derives from the similarities in the problems of their public unfunded systems and the political and social acceptability of retaining a highly redistributive pillar. A balanced reform is politically feasible, while prolonged delays can lead to the collapse of the existing weak and unsustainable systems. This paper - a product of the Financial Sector Development Department - is a revised, expanded version of a paper presented at the conference Pension Privatization in Latin America: Lessons for Central and Eastern Europe, Airlie House, Virginia, April 27-29, 1995. It is part of a larger effort in the department to study private pension funds and contractual savings.

Transformation of Social Security

Transformation of Social Security
Author: Katharina Müller
Publisher: Springer Science & Business Media
Total Pages: 306
Release: 2012-12-06
Genre: Political Science
ISBN: 3642586546

This collection of papers focuses on the recent pension reform experiences in Central-Eastern Europe, while starting from a broader theoretical and empirical context. It provides evidence for the political feasibility of radical pension reform, considered unlikely in the West. The approach is both multi-disciplinary and cross-regional: The book contains papers by economists, political scientists and sociologists. The authors come from Germany, Poland, Hungary, the Czech Republic, and the US. The volume consists of four parts: First, general questions of transformation and social security in post-1989 Central Eastern Europe are addressed, followed by an introduction into issues and role models in the international pension reform debate. Then, three Central European country cases are presented, analysing institutional legacies, recent reform measures and relevant political actors. A comparative section on Central-Eastern European pension reforms concludes this book.

The Political Economy of Pension Reform in Central-Eastern Europe

The Political Economy of Pension Reform in Central-Eastern Europe
Author: Katharina Müller
Publisher: Edward Elgar Publishing
Total Pages: 248
Release: 1999
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN:

This volume contains the findings of the research project "Institutional Change in Social Security: Pension Reforms in Poland, Hungary and the Czech Republic," which was completed in early 1999. Muller, a research fellow with the Frankfurt Institute for Transformation Studies at the European University Viadrina, examines the partial privatization path that Poland and Hungary chose, and compares their Latin American-styled methods to those of the Czech Republic (which fall well within the boundaries of the Bismarckian-Beveridgean pension traditions). In particular, she looks at which structural-institutional and actor-related factors account for radial pension reform. Annotation copyrighted by Book News, Inc., Portland, OR

Privatising Old-age Security

Privatising Old-age Security
Author: Katharina Müller
Publisher: Edward Elgar Publishing
Total Pages: 200
Release: 2003
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN:

This is a comparative political economy interpretation of policy reform applied to pensions in eight bold reformer countries of Latin America and Eastern Europe. The author shows what a multi-faceted, sometimes elusive undertaking reform is, involving many different actors with often conflicting goals. Considered within the specific policy and economic contexts, the analysis confronts pension system reforms in countries that have been going through important or deep systemic transformation, and that have used pension system reform also to pursue broader and deeper changes and macroeconomic stabilization

Reforming Pensions in Developing and Transition Countries

Reforming Pensions in Developing and Transition Countries
Author: K. Hujo
Publisher: Palgrave Macmillan
Total Pages: 346
Release: 2014-01-01
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 9781349484515

This book moves beyond technical studies of pension systems by addressing the political economy of pension reform in different contexts. It provides insights into key issues related to pension policy and its developmental implications, drawing on selected country studies in Africa, Asia, Eastern Europe, the Middle East, and Latin America.

Coverage Under Old Age Security Programs and Protection for the Uninsured

Coverage Under Old Age Security Programs and Protection for the Uninsured
Author: Estelle James
Publisher: World Bank Publications
Total Pages: 25
Release: 1999
Genre: Old age pensions
ISBN:

The shift toward social security systems with a tighter link between benefits and contributions will make such systems more fiscally sustainable. But to protect the uninsured and underinsured, such programs should be complemented by better social assistance programs for low-income groups.

Pension Reform in Latin America and Its Lessons for International Policymakers

Pension Reform in Latin America and Its Lessons for International Policymakers
Author: Tapen Sinha
Publisher: Springer Science & Business Media
Total Pages: 310
Release: 2012-12-06
Genre: Political Science
ISBN: 146154503X

The experience of privatization of social security has been predominantly in the Latin American region. Eight countries have undertaken either full or partial privatization of pensions: Argentina, Bolivia, Chile, Colombia, El Salvador, Mexico, Peru, and Uruguay. What did the policymakers expect? Were expectations realized? Can we learn anything from the collective experience of these countries? Can they be applied to other countries that are aspiring to privatize? How did the World Bank and other international institutions affect these policies? Pension Reform in Latin America and Its Lessons for International Policymakers analyzes in detail these important questions. The book begins with a detailed account of economic conditions in Latin America. It then discusses various models that policymakers rely on. Starting with a purely demographic model, it lays out advanced models of overlapping generations of Samuelson. The book gives extensive details of privatized pensions in each of the eight reforming countries. Two chapters are devoted to analyzing the reform in each country. Finally, detailed lessons are drawn that will help shape the debate for policymakers in other countries.