Simulation-based Approach to Estimate the Capacity of a Temporary Freeway Work Zone Lane Closure

Simulation-based Approach to Estimate the Capacity of a Temporary Freeway Work Zone Lane Closure
Author: Diego F. Arguea
Publisher:
Total Pages:
Release: 2006
Genre:
ISBN:

ABSTRACT: The Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) is interested in updating its methodologies for estimating capacities on freeway work zones in Florida. The current methods have not been modified since 1995, and the FDOT is particularly interested in new ways to facilitate the scheduling and managing of lane closures. This thesis proposes new simulation-based models for estimating the capacity of a temporary freeway work zone lane closure. Some of the factors considered in model development include the location of the upstream warning sign, the presence of trucks, the presence of law enforcement and/or heavy equipment, and the length of the work zone. In addition to these inputs, the average speeds per vehicle and the vehicular lane distributions for specific network links were considered in model development. A large matrix of scenarios was created so that the effects of all combinations of factors could be observed. Data were collected from simulation of these scenarios using the software package CORSIM 5.1. Three lane closure configurations (2-to-1, 3-to-2, and 3-to-1) were simulated and one model for estimating capacity was developed for each. All models for each lane closure configuration consider the input factors named previously as well as average speeds per vehicle and lane distributions of vehicles upstream of the work zone lane closure. The final models show the effects of each of these factors on the throughput capacity of a freeway lane closure. A higher fraction of vehicles in the to-be closed lane(s) prior to the work zone leads to a significant decrease in capacity. Likewise, higher speeds in the to-be closed lane(s) also lead to a capacity decrease. The result of this simulation modeling offers valuable insights into the relative capacities under different geometric configurations and traffic stream scenarios. Future research is recommended to calibrate the models to actual field conditions.

Updated Short-term Freeway Work Zone Lane Closure Capacity Values

Updated Short-term Freeway Work Zone Lane Closure Capacity Values
Author: Raymond A. Krammes
Publisher:
Total Pages: 44
Release: 1992
Genre: Express highways
ISBN:

Recommendations on estimating the capacity of short-term freeway work zone lane closures are presented. The recommendations are based upon 45 hours of capacity counts at 33 different work zones between 1987 and 1991. These new data indicate average capacities for short-term freeway work zone lane closures from 3 to 1 lanes and from 2 to 1 lanes that are significantly higher than older values reported in the 1985 Highway Capacity Manual. A base capacity value of 1,600 pcphpl is recommended for all short-term freeway work zone lane closure configurations.

Work Zone Simulation Model

Work Zone Simulation Model
Author: T. H. Maze
Publisher:
Total Pages: 52
Release: 1999
Genre: Automobile drivers
ISBN:

To support the analysis of driver behavior at rural freeway work zone lane closure merge points, Center for Transportation Research and Education staff collected traffic data at merge areas using video image processing technology. The collection of data and the calculation of the capacity of lane closures are reported in a companion report, "Traffic Management Strategies for Merge Areas in Rural Interstate Work Zones". These data are used in the work reported in this document and are used to calibrate a microscopic simulation model of a typical, Iowa rural freeway lane closure. The model developed is a high fidelity computer simulation with an animation interface. It simulates traffic operations at a work zone lane closure. This model enables traffic engineers to visually demonstrate the forecasted delay that is likely to result when freeway reconstruction makes it necessary to close freeway lanes. Further, the model is also sensitive to variations in driver behavior and is used to test the impact of slow moving vehicles and other driver behaviors. This report consists of two parts. The first part describes the development of the work zone simulation model. The simulation analysis is calibrated and verified through data collected at a work zone in Interstate Highway 80 in Scott County, Iowa. The second part is a user's manual for the simulation model, which is provided to assist users with its set up and operation. No prior computer programming skills are required to use the simulation model.

Estimation of Traffic Impacts at Work Zones

Estimation of Traffic Impacts at Work Zones
Author: Praveen Kumar Edara
Publisher:
Total Pages: 21
Release: 2006
Genre: Highway capacity
ISBN:

Assessing the safety and mobility impacts of work zones across the project development phases of road construction and maintenance projects is an emphasis area of the Federal Highway Administration's Final Rule on Work Zone Safety and Mobility1 (Final Rule). Specifically, the design phase of developing traffic control plans requires performing a traffic analysis to estimate queue lengths, travel times, and delays to determine lane closure times. State departments of transportation (DOTs) must comply with the requirements of the Final Rule by October 2007. To this end, this study was conducted to provide the Virginia Department of Transportation (VDOT) with the state-of-the-practice tools that are available and used by other state agencies for estimating the traffic impacts at work zones. The researcher found that all models based on the Highway Capacity Manual (HCM) assume capacity as an exogenous variable that is given as input to the model; delay and queue length are dependent on capacity. A good estimate of the capacity of a work zone bottleneck is essential to obtain an accurate estimate of traffic impacts. The capacity charts in HCM 1994 were determined for work zones in Texas based on studies conducted before 1982. Based on the recommendations in HCM 2000, it is clear that the 1994 capacity charts significantly under-predict the capacity values at short-term freeway work zones. However, it is possible to obtain realistic capacity estimates from HCM 2000 by using base capacity values specific to the state and applying the necessary adjustment factors for intensity of work activity, effect of heavy vehicles, and presence of ramps in close proximity to the work zone. Data intensiveness, level of effort, and accuracy of the estimates are the key elements state DOTs use to choose the tools for traffic impact analysis. It can be safely assumed that most of the HCM-based tools are easy to use, are not data intensive, and generate quick results, with the exception of QuickZone, which could be data intensive and might require greater user effort. Many state DOTs use the size of the project as an element. Comprehensive tools such as QuickZone and microscopic simulation that are highly detailed and incorporate traveler response to the prevailing traffic conditions might be suitable for use for large projects. There is evidence that simple spreadsheet models and the QUEWZ model produce more accurate estimates of traffic impacts than do QuickZone and microscopic simulation. The inability of many available traffic simulation models to model the oversaturated conditions at work zone bottlenecks is one reason for the erroneous estimates. The conclusions in this study should help VDOT choose the appropriate tool(s) for estimating the traffic impacts in and around work zones. This is a very high priority for VDOT's Traffic Engineering Division as it works on the development of an agency-wide plan to comply with the Final Rule for roll out by the end of 2006.

Work Zones and Their Impact on User Costs

Work Zones and Their Impact on User Costs
Author: Ghulam H. Bham
Publisher:
Total Pages: 56
Release: 1999
Genre: Highway capacity
ISBN:

This report defines a work zone, its capacity, and how it is estimated. The importance of capacity is also mentioned since it is directly used in the calculation of user delay due to a work zone. The impact of delay on user costs is also discussed. A methodology is presented which relates queue delay with ADT. Queue delay due to a work zone is calculated using a plot between time, cumulative volume, and capacity. The area between the curves represents queue delay. Three software packages are evaluated for calculation of user delay and cost due to a work zone. None of them were adequate for calculating delay due to queue formation.

Corridor Traffic Management for Major Highway Reconstruction

Corridor Traffic Management for Major Highway Reconstruction
Author:
Publisher:
Total Pages: 284
Release: 1986
Genre: Roads
ISBN:

This publication, which describes reconstruction experiences, gives case studies which document the varied projects, and gives specific ideas for the management of major highway reconstruction. This report also discusses the use of incentive/disincentive provisions for early contract completion. Ways to expedite expressway and bridge rehabilitation are summarized, and a policy statememt is provided on the application of traffic management actions. Abstracts and summaries are given of recently published literature in the area of corridor traffic management for temporary flow disruptions.