Regulating and Supervising Credit Rating Agencies in the European Union

Regulating and Supervising Credit Rating Agencies in the European Union
Author: Gudula Deipenbrock
Publisher:
Total Pages: 17
Release: 2016
Genre:
ISBN:

This paper addresses a pressing issue in connection with adequately tackling the recent financial crises: the regulation and supervision of credit rating agencies in the European Union. The paper gives an overview of the recently reformed regulatory and supervisory regime for credit rating agencies in the European Union and critically assesses its potential to address effectively and efficiently the flaws of the credit rating market. The paper has been completed in September 2011.

EU Supervision of Credit Rating Agencies

EU Supervision of Credit Rating Agencies
Author:
Publisher:
Total Pages: 0
Release: 2015
Genre: Credit bureaus
ISBN: 9789287235862

The 2008 financial crisis focused attention on the credit rating agencies and their impact on financial markets. At the time, there was very little regulation of the agencies in Europe. In 2011, the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) was created to register, monitor and supervise them. This report examines whether ESMA has successfully established itself as the credit rating agencies watchdog for the EU. We conclude that while ESMA has laid down good foundations, its rules and guidelines are not yet complete and significant risks remain to be addressed in the future.--

Credit Rating Agencies on the Watch List

Credit Rating Agencies on the Watch List
Author: Raquel García Alcubilla
Publisher: OUP Oxford
Total Pages: 320
Release: 2012-03-29
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 0191640999

Credit rating agencies have been criticized for their role in the financial crisis by understating credit risk. The US subprime mortgage crisis highlighted the systemic relevance of the rating agencies and the deficiencies in their activities; this led to an international consensus to regulate the rating business. Written by those involved in developing European Legislation, this book explains EU Regulation in the context of global initiatives undertaken by the G-20, the Financial Stability Board, and IOSCO to address failures within the rating industry. Through an in-depth analysis of the EU Regulation's requirements on governance, conflicts of interest, methodologies, and transparency, the book provides a clear explanation of how rating agencies operate and how the identified failures have been addressed. Moreover, it examines the supervisory and enforcement powers of ESMA, the EU authority in charge of the registration and oversight of rating agencies. This is complemented with an analysis of guidance from supervisors (ESMA and EBA), IOSCO's recommendations, and US legislation. The book discusses possible new regulatory developments in areas such as the agencies' business model, competition, civil liability, and ratings of sovereign debt, in light of the Euro debt sovereign crisis. It concludes with the authors' support for an enhanced regulatory and oversight coordination at international level and for the implementation of the necessary steps to reduce the existing over-reliance on ratings.

Credit Rating Agencies and European Financial Market Supervision

Credit Rating Agencies and European Financial Market Supervision
Author: Gudula Deipenbrock
Publisher:
Total Pages: 21
Release: 2016
Genre:
ISBN:

Credit rating agencies have been a core concern in the reform of the global and European financial architecture prompted by the financial crisis. The European Regulation on Credit Rating Agencies (CRA Regulation) entered into force at the end of 2009. Activities of credit rating agencies and the issuance of ratings had previously not been regulated in most Member States of the European Union. The importance of rating activities in financial markets and their regulation is not disputed. The previous reluctance of legislators - national and European - to regulate and supervise the rating sector is difficult to justify. This became even clearer with the financial crisis and with the assessment of its causes. The supervision of credit rating agencies became a pressing issue with the CRA Regulation. The European Commission piloted, in parallel, a fundamental overhaul of financial supervision in Europe aiming at a more efficient, integrated and sustainable European system of supervision. The legal acts introducing the new European financial supervisory architecture build on the 2009 Report of the High Level Group of Experts (the de Laroisière report) and came into force, recently. The new European system of supervision paved the way for making progress with a first reform of the CRA Regulation introducing a single European supervisory authority for credit rating agencies in the European Union. We take stock of the regulatory regime for credit rating agencies in its second year of application, and its - politically agreed - first reform.

Credit Rating Agencies

Credit Rating Agencies
Author: Mohammed Hemraj
Publisher: Springer
Total Pages: 291
Release: 2015-06-22
Genre: Law
ISBN: 3319179276

The book examines the role of credit rating agencies (CRAs) in the subprime mortgage crisis. The CRAs are blamed for awarding risky securities ‘3-A’ investment grade status and then failing to downgrade them quickly enough when circumstances changed, which led to investors suffering substantial losses. The causes identified by the regulators for the gatekeeper failure were conflicts of interest (as the issuers of these securities pay for the ratings); lack of competition (as the Big Three CRAs have dominated the market share); and lack of regulation for CRAs. The book examines how the regulators, both in the US and EU, have sought to address these problems by introducing soft law self-regulation in accordance with the International Organisation of Securities Commissions Code and hard law statutory regulation, such as that found in the “Reform Act” and “Dodd-Frank Act” in the US and similar provisions in the EU. The highly topical book examines these provisions in detail by using a doctrinal black-letter law method to assess the success of the regulators in redressing the problems identified. It also examines the US case law regulation relating to the legal liability of CRAs. The book examines whether the regulations introduced have had a deterrent effect on the actions of CRAs, whether investors are compensated for their losses, and how the regulators have dealt with the issues of conflicts of interest and an anti-competitive environment. Should liability be introduced for CRAs through changes in the law so as to compel them to issue reliable ratings and solve the current problems? The book seeks to simplify the complex issues involved and is backed by concrete evidence; as such, it will appeal to both the well-informed and the lay general public who are interested in learning more about the role of CRAs in the sub-prime mortgage crisis and regulators’ attempts to remedy the situation. Novice readers can familiarise themselves with the legal and financial terminology used by referring to the glossary at the end of the book.

The Governance of Credit Rating Agencies

The Governance of Credit Rating Agencies
Author: Andrea Miglionico
Publisher: Edward Elgar Publishing
Total Pages: 360
Release: 2019
Genre: LAW
ISBN: 1786439948

The global crisis revealed that credit rating agencies (CRAs) are capable of bringing about potential distortions in the financial sector, thereby resulting in a reduction in market confidence which, in turn, influences negotiations and expectations. CRAs need to be held accountable for lack of transparency and inaccurate ratings, however the existing regulatory framework does not secure adequate investor protection. This book provides a new and important contribution to research in the area, at a crucial time in the debate around financial regulation and investment regimes.

Regulating and Supervising European Financial Markets

Regulating and Supervising European Financial Markets
Author: Mads Andenas
Publisher: Springer
Total Pages: 438
Release: 2016-08-16
Genre: Law
ISBN: 3319321749

The book analyses the institutions of the European financial market supervision and the challenges of financial markets. The current European supervisory structure for financial markets represents a major development in European supervisory history. Its operation however has to be explored and analysed critically. Has it gone far enough to provide a sufficiently comprehensive and resilient system to reduce or mitigate systemic risks and handle financial crises? Some claim it has gone too far already. Fresh and rigorous critical legal and economic analysis from an independent scholarly perspective are needed to assess whether the institutional design of the European supervisory architecture has proved itself to be an efficient and effective model. This book discusses many dimensions of the structure and workings of the European system from various angles providing different dimensions. The book makes an important contribution to the limited literature on financial market supervision.

EU Supervision of Credit Rating Agencies

EU Supervision of Credit Rating Agencies
Author:
Publisher:
Total Pages: 76
Release: 2015
Genre: Credit bureaus
ISBN:

"The 2008 financial crisis focused attention on the credit rating agencies and their impact on financial markets. At the time, there was very little regulation of the agencies in Europe. In 2011, the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) was created to register, monitor and supervise them. This report examines whether ESMA has successfully established itself as the credit rating agencies watchdog for the EU. We conclude that while ESMA has laid down good foundations, its rules and guidelines are not yet complete and significant risks remain to be addressed in the future."--Publisher's description.

Regulating Credit Rating Agencies

Regulating Credit Rating Agencies
Author: Aline Darbellay
Publisher: Edward Elgar Publishing
Total Pages: 0
Release: 2013
Genre: Credit bureaus
ISBN: 9780857939357

This highly topical book examines how the leading credit rating agencies - Moody's, Standard & Poor's and Fitch - have risen to prominence in the wake of the financial crisis. It investigates how the Big Three have become ever more profitable even though the quality of their ratings has declined and rating scandals have tarnished their reputation. After a century of being left quasi-unregulated the rating industry is now subject to sweeping reforms. This informative study analyzes the post-crisis overhaul in the United States and the European Union. The focus lies on the interactions between regulatory intervention and competitive incentives among the Big Three. This book highlights the challenges faced by policymakers trying to regulate the rating industry and simultaneously decrease over-reliance on ratings. Regulating Credit Rating Agencies will appeal to academics in law and economics, practitioners, policymakers, lawmakers and regulators. Contents Foreword Part I: Prelude to the Credit Rating Industry 1. Introduction 2. History of Credit Rating Agencies 3. Description of the Credit Rating Industry Part II: Regulatory Structure 4. Rating-based Regulations 5. Regulatory Treatment of Credit Rating Agencies 6. Regulatory Trends Part III: Uses and Abuses of Credit Ratings in Structured Finance 7. Growth of the Structured Finance Segment 8. Wrong Incentives in the Credit Rating Industry 9. Regulatory Response to the Problems of Structured Finance Ratings Part IV: System-wide Effects of Credit Rating Downgrades 10. System-relevance of Credit Ratings 11. Market Reactions to Credit Rating Downgrades and their Consequences 12. Regulatory Response to the Systemic Issue Part V: Trends and Outlook 13. Restoring Competition in the Credit Rating Industry 14. Concluding Remarks Bibliography Index