Internet Usage and State Sales Tax Competition

Internet Usage and State Sales Tax Competition
Author:
Publisher:
Total Pages: 138
Release: 2007
Genre:
ISBN:

This paper examines the influence of increasing access to the Internet and increasing online purchasing on sales tax competition among the states. Prior research indicates that the tax rates set by a state's geographical neighbors influence the tax rate set by the home state. As consumers gain access to the Internet and begin to participate in online shopping, their opportunity cost to participate in cross-border shopping decreases and their "mobility" may increase due to the ease of purchasing from vendors lacking nexus in the consumer's home state. Thus, states may begin to respond less to the sales tax changes of their geographic neighbors and may begin to define competitors differently. I find that increases in both the percentage of the population having Internet access and the percentage of the population making online purchases influence the response of a state to its neighbors' tax rates. Specifically, states with higher percentages of either of these measures have more positive response functions when examining the "effective Internet tax rate" definition of neighbor. States appear to respond only slightly to changes in the tax rates of their geographic neighbors. This paper also examines the influence of Internet usage on the sales tax revenues of the states by separating the influences of cross-border shopping through traditional means and through the Internet. Research finds that consumers who live near physical borders are more responsive to tax differences than are consumers who live farther from physical borders. As more consumers access the Internet and begin to purchase goods online, all consumers may become as responsive to tax differences as are those who live near physical borders. Thus, both traditional means of cross-border shopping and cross-border shopping through use of the Internet would be expected to influence the sales tax revenues of a state. Surprisingly, I find that sales tax revenue per capita appears to increase with an increase in my measure of Internet-based cross-border shopping. This may indicate that online shopping does not act entirely as a substitute for local forms of shopping but rather represents an increase in consumption.

State Taxation of Internet Transactions

State Taxation of Internet Transactions
Author: Steven Maguire
Publisher: DIANE Publishing
Total Pages: 19
Release: 2011
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 1437988105

The 2011 co-called e-commerce volume at approx. $3.5 trillion. The volume of e-commerce is expected to increase and state and local governments are concerned because collection of sales tax on these transactions is difficut to enforce. Under current law, states cannot reach beyond their borders and compel out-of-state Internet vendors (those without nexus in the buyer¿s state) to collect the use tax owed by state residents and businesses. The Supreme Court ruled that requiring remote vendors to collect the use tax would pose an undue burden on interstate commerce. Estimates put this lost tax revenue at approx. $8.6 billion. This report discusses the Streamlined Sales and use Tax Agree. and related economic issues. Illus. This is a print on demand report.

Sales Tax Competition

Sales Tax Competition
Author: Nicholas Alan Saxon
Publisher:
Total Pages: 210
Release: 2013
Genre: Electronic books
ISBN:

The exhaustive existing literature on sales tax competition has had a focus on state data or case-studies of specific areas. This is natural because these data are usually easily obtained, and the concept of a national panel of sales tax rate data below a state level has been out of reach thus far. This paper attempts to further the literature by bringing this focus on sales taxes down to county level business data and adds county sales tax rates to the already intensely-covered state sales tax rate. Further, this paper covers all counties within the United States in order to provide better insight into the use and growth of the sales tax at sub-national levels. Utilizing data from 2002 through 2011, it is found that sales taxes have a significant negative impact to an overall county economy's annual payroll and employment. This is in stark contrast to the positive gains policymakers achieve for society by raising revenue to provide services by raising sales tax rates, and the trade-off may suggest raising sales tax rates is not beneficial overall, and may do much more harm than good. Further, it is confirmed that sales taxes tend to indicate a "friendliness" to the retail industry and a neglect of the manufacturing industry, whereby the institution of, or an increase in, a state or county sales tax rate can significantly reduce the manufacturing business activity within that county.

Dynamic Sales Tax Competition

Dynamic Sales Tax Competition
Author: Melissa Gentry
Publisher:
Total Pages:
Release: 2020
Genre:
ISBN:

We examine both vertical and horizontal tax competition over time by studying the strategic response of county sales taxation to state sales taxes and to cross-border neighboring municipalities' combined (state and county) taxes. Using county and state sales tax data from 2003 through 2009, we employ both static and dynamic panel analysis as well as an instrumental variables approach in combination with a border analysis. Our results confirm the presence of tax competition in the cross section, as previous studies have found. Results from the fixedeffects and dynamic panel analysis also indicate the presence of vertical competition, though quite small, as counties are consistently responsive to changes in their own state sales tax level across all models and specifications. However, the panel findings suggest little to no horizontal tax competition. Following Parchet (2019), we address additional concerns about endogeneity by instrumenting the neighboring-county sales tax rate with the state-level sales tax rate of the neighboring state. Results from instrumental variables analysis reinforce the presence of a small vertical tax competition between local and state sales tax policies. Interestingly, our results, like those of Parchet (2019), indicate that cross-border local sales tax rates act as strategic substitutes.

Sell Globally, Tax Locally

Sell Globally, Tax Locally
Author: Michael S. Greve
Publisher: American Enterprise Institute
Total Pages: 64
Release: 2003
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 9780844771700

This book discusses the flaws of destination-based taxation and makes the theoretical case for origin-based taxation.

State Taxation of Internet Transactions

State Taxation of Internet Transactions
Author: Steven Maguire
Publisher: Createspace Independent Publishing Platform
Total Pages: 0
Release: 2011-11
Genre:
ISBN: 9781470047832

The United States Bureau of the Census estimated that $3.4 trillion worth of retail and wholesale transactions were conducted over the Internet in 2009. That amount was 16.8% of all U.S. shipments and sales in that year. Other estimates projected the 2011 so-called e-commerce volume at approximately $3.9 trillion. The volume of e-commerce is expected to increase and state and local governments are concerned because collection of sales taxes on these transactions is difficult to enforce. Under current law, states cannot reach beyond their borders and compel out-of-state Internet vendors (those without nexus in the buyer's state) to collect the use tax owed by state residents and businesses. The Supreme Court ruled in 1967 that requiring remote vendors to collect the use tax would pose an undue burden on interstate commerce. Estimates put this lost tax revenue at approximately $11.4 billion in 2012. Congress is involved because interstate commerce typically falls under the Commerce Clause of the Constitution. Opponents of remote vendor sales and use tax collection cite the complexity of the myriad state and local sales tax systems and the difficulty vendors would have in collecting and remitting use taxes. Proponents would like Congress to change the law and allow states to require out-of-state vendors without nexus to collect state use taxes. These proponents acknowledge that simplification and harmonization of state tax systems are likely prerequisites for Congress to consider approval of increased collection authority for states. A number of states have been working together to harmonize sales tax collection and have created the Streamlined Sales and Use Tax Agreement (SSUTA). The SSUTA member states hope that Congress can be persuaded to allow them to require out-of-state vendors to collect taxes from customers in SSUTA member states. In the 112th Congress, S. 1452 and H.R. 2701 (Senator Durbin and Representative Conyers) would grant SSUTA member states the authority to compel out-of-state vendors in other member states to collect sales and use taxes. In addition, H.R. 3179 (Representative Womack) would also grant states the authority to compel out-of-state vendors to collect use taxes provided selected simplification efforts are implemented. A related issue is the "Internet Tax Moratorium." The relatively narrow moratorium prohibits (1) new taxes on Internet access services and (2) multiple or discriminatory taxes on Internet commerce. Congress has extended the "Internet Tax Moratorium" twice. The most recent extension expires November 1, 2014. The moratorium is distinct from the remote use tax collection issue, but has been linked in past debates. An analysis of the Internet tax moratorium is beyond the scope of this report. Congressional Research Service.

Internet Access Tax Moratorium

Internet Access Tax Moratorium
Author: United States. Government Accountability Office
Publisher: DIANE Publishing
Total Pages: 55
Release: 2006
Genre: Electronic commerce
ISBN: 1428930353

Internet Commerce and State Sales and Use Taxes

Internet Commerce and State Sales and Use Taxes
Author: Steven Maguire
Publisher:
Total Pages: 0
Release: 2001
Genre: Electronic commerce
ISBN:

State governments rely on sales and use taxes for approximately one-third (32.3%) of their total tax revenue - or approximately $174 billion in FY2000. Local governments derived 16.4% of their tax revenue or $51.6 billion from local sales and use taxes in FY1999. Both state and local sales taxes are collected by vendors at the time of transaction and are levied at a percentage of a product's retail price. Alternatively, use taxes are not collected by vendors if they do not have nexus (loosely defined as a physical presence) in the consumer's state. Consumers are required to remit use taxes to their taxing jurisdiction. However, compliance with this requirement is quite low. Because of the low compliance, many observers suggest that the expansion of the internet as a means of transacting business across state lines, both from business to consumer (B to C) and from business to business (B to B), threatens to diminish the ability of state and local governments to collect sales and use taxes. Congress has a role in this issue because commerce between parties in different states conducted over the Internet falls under the Commerce Clause of the Constitution. Congress can either take an active or passive role in the "Internet tax" debate. This report intends to clarify important issues in the Internet tax debate.