Essays on the Economics of Education and Language of Instruction

Essays on the Economics of Education and Language of Instruction
Author: Lyliana Elizabeth Gayoso de Ervin
Publisher:
Total Pages: 121
Release: 2016
Genre:
ISBN:

In the third essay, I use survival analysis techniques to identify factors affecting primary school drop out by Guarani, Spanish, and bilingual speaking students. The results indicate that language-disadvantaged students, the Guarani speakers, are more likely to drop out at any grade after second grade, and the risk of dropping out is highest after sixth grade. The overall findings of this dissertation reveal that language plays an important role in educational outcomes.

Essays on the Economics of Education

Essays on the Economics of Education
Author: Richard Wells Patterson
Publisher:
Total Pages: 135
Release: 2015
Genre:
ISBN:

This dissertation examines various economic factors that influence student academic performance. In the first essay, I explore the role of behavioral factors in educational performance by testing whether time-management tools can improve academic outcomes for online students. I design three software tools including (1) a commitment device that allows students to pre-commit to time limits on distracting Internet activities, (2) a reminder tool that is triggered by time spent on distracting websites, and (3) a focusing tool that allows students to block distracting sites when they go to the course website. I test the impact of these tools in a large-scale randomized experiment (n=657) conducted in a massive open online course (MOOC) hosted by Stanford University. Relative to students in the control group, students in the commitment device treatment spend 24% more time working on the course, receive course grades that are 0.29 standard deviations higher, and are 40% more likely to complete the course. In contrast, outcomes for students in the reminder and focusing treatments are not statistically distinguishable from the control. These results suggest that tools designed to address procrastination can have a significant impact on online student performance. In the second essay, I examine whether trends in parenting time could help explain the black-white test score gap. I use data from the American Time Use Survey (ATUS) to examine the patterns in the time black and white children receive from mothers at each age between birth and age 14 and compare these patterns to corresponding test-score gaps documented in the Early Childhood Longitudinal Study (ECLS-K). I observe that black children spend significantly less time with their mothers than white children in the first years of life and that differences are concentrated in activities that may be especially important during these years. Differences in parenting time, however, rapidly decline with age. Contrastingly, when socioeconomic variables are controlled, black-white test score gaps are small in kindergarten, but then grow over time. The results of this study suggest that contemporaneous differences in parent time are unlikely to be a significant factor in black-white test score trends. In the third essay, coauthored with Jordan Matsudaira, I study whether charter school unionization impacts student academic outcomes. We use administrative school-level data coupled with data on the timing of union recognition collected via our own public records requests (PRR) and records of unionization from the state Public Employment Relations Board (PERB) to construct difference-in-difference estimates the of the impact of teacher unionization on student outcomes. We find that unionization has a positive and statically significant impact on student math performance and a positive but only marginally significant impact on english performance. In our preferred estimates, we find that unions increase average grade-level math test scores by 0.17-0.21 standard deviations (SD) and English scores by 0.06-0.08 SD. These estimates allow us to rule out even modest negative effects of unionization on student academic outcomes.

Essays on the Economics of Education

Essays on the Economics of Education
Author: Peter Sturmthal Bergman
Publisher:
Total Pages: 123
Release: 2012
Genre: Academic achievement
ISBN:

I study three separate questions in this dissertation. In Chapter 1, I examine how information frictions between parents and their children affect human capital investment, and how much reducing those friction can improve student effort and achievement. I find that providing additional information to parents regarding missing assignments is a potentially cost-effective strategy to increase parental investments and improve student achievement. In Chapter 2, we measure the impact of high-quality charter schools on teen fertility using admission lotteries to several Los Angeles charter schools as a natural experiment. We find evidence that admission to high-quality charter schools can substantially reduce teen pregnancies. In Chapter 3, we semi-parametrically estimate teacher effects on student test scores using data from the Los Angeles Unified School District. We document that there is significantly more within-teacher variation in teachers' effects than across teacher variation. We find that interacting the teacher indicator variables with a function of the students' lagged test scores captures most of the nonlinearities, preserves the heterogeneity of teacher effects, and provides more accurate estimates.

Essays on the Economics of Education

Essays on the Economics of Education
Author: William Jesse Wood
Publisher:
Total Pages: 0
Release: 2022
Genre: Electronic dissertations
ISBN:

This dissertation provides three chapters on the economics of education. In the first chapter, I provide evidence that diversifying the labor supply of teachers to better reflect the racial distribution of students improves noncognitive outcomes for students of color without diminishing outcomes for White students. I use administrative data spanning 2007 to 2017 from the Los Angeles Unified School District, one of the most racially diverse school districts in the country, to measure the effect of student-teacher race matching on various noncognitive and behavior outcomes: GPA, work habits, cooperation, grade retention, suspensions, absences, and a data generated noncognitive index. I mitigate the concern that race matches are endogenous by including school-grade and student fixed effects in a linear regression model. My findings indicate that students of color are expected to experience increases in GPA, work habits, and cooperation and see decreases in suspensions and absenteeism when matched with a teacher of the same race. I do not find statistically significant effects on White students' outcomes. Because noncognitive outcomes lead to higher high school graduation rates, college enrollment rates, and wages, such effects could lead to a tightening in the achievement and wage gap found between students of color and White students. This result can be achieved with an increase in institutional efforts to ensure teacher populations more closely reflect that of their students. The second chapter estimates the impact of race matched faculty (i.e., any teacher outside of a particular student's classroom) on student test scores. While the student population rapidly diversifies, the teaching corps' diversification continues to lag behind. For example, the proportion of Latino student enrollment in public schools has increased from 11 to 27 percent in just the last two decades. In contrast, the share of Latino public school teachers during this same period has increased from 3 to only 9 percent (Pew Research Center, 2021). If the disparity between student and teacher racial distributions continues to grow, students of color may find it more difficult to benefit from direct student-teacher race matching. However, it may still be possible for students to benefit from same-race teachers even if they are not placed in the same classroom. Using administrative panel data between school years 2008-09 through 2017-18 from Los Angeles Unified School District, I estimate that Latino students see positive impacts of race matched faculty. By basing this study in an area with a large proportion of Latino students and teachers, we can fill a gap within the literature by examining the effects of race match and faculty race match on Latino students. The findings indicate that matching Latino students to racially congruent teachers and faculty can improve math and English Language Arts test scores. Increasing the supply of Latino teachers may provide a crucial catalyst in decreasing the achievement gaps found between Latino and white students. The final chapter continues along the lines of educational equity. The success of many students with disabilities (SWDs) depends on access to high-quality general education teachers. Yet, most teacher value-added measures (VAMs) fail to distinguish between a teacher's effectiveness in educating students with and without disabilities. I create two VAMs: one focusing on teachers' effectiveness in improving outcomes for SWDs, and one for non-SWDs. I find top-performing teachers for non-SWDs often have relatively lower VAMs for SWDs, and SWDs sort to teachers with lower scores in both VAMs. Overall, SWD-specific VAMs may be more suitable for identifying which teachers have a history of effectiveness with SWDs and could play a role in ensuring that students are being optimally assigned to these teachers.

Essays on the Economics of Education

Essays on the Economics of Education
Author: Elizabeth Dhuey
Publisher: ProQuest
Total Pages: 256
Release: 2007
Genre:
ISBN: 9780549306092

The final chapter is "The Persistence of Early Childhood Maturity: International Evidence of Long-Run Age Effects." A continuum of ages exists at school entry due to the use of a single school cut-off date--making the "oldest" children approximately twenty percent older than the "youngest" children. We provide substantial evidence that these initial maturity differences have long lasting effects on student performance across OECD countries. In particular, the youngest members of each cohort score 4-12 percentiles lower than the oldest members in grade four and 2-9 percentiles lower in grade eight. In fact, data from Canada and the United States shows that the youngest members of each cohort are even less likely to attend university.

Essays on the Economics of Education

Essays on the Economics of Education
Author: Yusuke Jinnai
Publisher:
Total Pages: 117
Release: 2013
Genre: Bonuses (Employee fringe benefits)
ISBN:

"Although numerous reforms for improving public education have been proposed in the United States, the effects of implemented programs remain controversial. Focusing on recent reform policies, my dissertation examines the impact of school choice, educational accountability, and teacher performance-pay programs on student achievement. Chapter One analyzes the effects of introducing charter schools, fast-growing school-choice programs, on students at neighboring traditional public schools. Unlike prior work, which estimates the effects at the school level, this study examines the impact at the grade level by exploiting the fact that charter schools expand their grade ranges over time. I define direct impact as the impact on traditional-school students in overlapping grades and indirect impact as the impact on those in non-overlapping grades. Using student-level panel data from North Carolina, this study shows that the entry of charter schools generates a positive and significant direct impact on student achievement. Moreover, I demonstrate that one-quarter of the positive direct impact is driven by student sorting while three-quarters result from competition. Chapter Two presents evidence from a regression-discontinuity analysis of North Carolina's accountability program, in which teachers are awarded an additional cash bonus for improving their students' achievement. Results show that teachers who failed to reach an expected benchmark for their students' achievement, resulting in no bonuses, performed significantly better in the subsequent year than those who reached this benchmark and thus received a bonus. Moreover, the results demonstrate that such impact disappeared once the state government repealed the pay scheme - another indication that teachers actively respond to monetary bonuses. Chapter Three examines the performance-pay program from a different viewpoint. To date, no studies in this literature have examined the potentially negative effects of repealing incentive bonuses. This chapter exploits North Carolina's policy changes, which first reduced and finally repealed its teacher incentive bonuses. This paper shows that, as a result, student achievement at the lowest-performing schools significantly decreased after the reduction and further decreased after the repeal of the bonus. These findings illustrate that once incentives are introduced it is not cost-free to reduce or remove them"--Pages v-vi.

Essays on the Economics of Quality Teaching

Essays on the Economics of Quality Teaching
Author: Joshua Hollinger
Publisher:
Total Pages: 0
Release: 2022
Genre: Education
ISBN:

"This thesis consists of three essays on the economics of education. These essays focus on how educators affect student outcomes in the short run and long run, and they assess the effects of policies aimed at educators' incentives. Chapter 1 considers the effects of test-score-based school accountability on students' test scores and long-run outcomes, as well as the relationship between these two different types of effects. While many education policies target test scores as a contemporaneous measure of student learning, a common concern is that these policies may generate higher test scores in a way that fails to translate to more important student outcomes in the long run. I use administrative data from North Carolina and two regression discontinuity designs to estimate the impact of school accountability pressure under No Child Left Behind on elementary students' test scores and their long-run outcomes at the end of high school. I find modest positive effects on elementary test scores and a significant increase in SAT scores years later. There is some evidence for a small increase in high school GPA, mixed evidence for an increase in students intending to attend a 4-year instead of a 2-year college, and no effect on high school graduation or intention to attend any college. Further evidence suggests the effect on SAT scores may be explained by persistent test-score effects in years after accountability exposure. Altogether, these results lend support to a mixed story for No Child Left Behind: while accountability pressure led to a long-run increase in skill captured by tests, these learning gains were not strong or broad enough to yield meaningful improvements in other long-run outcomes like educational attainment. Chapter 2 evaluates the test score effects of individual teacher performance pay schemes implemented in a number of high-need schools in North Carolina. Since performance bonuses were paid to teachers with value-added above a threshold toward the top of the district-wide distribution, I evaluate whether this policy generates larger incentives for teachers with higher probability of attaining the bonus. I find evidence for the opposite: those expected to be further away from the threshold increased their value-added, though the performance incentives did not have a significant overall effect. I show that the single-year value-added estimates are quite noisy, which likely was a reason for this. I also find that almost all of the teachers in these high-need schools were predicted to have value-added below the performance threshold. Both of these factors could explain the lack of overall incentive effectiveness. One possibility is that lower value-added teachers have more scope to improve effort. Chapter 3 addresses the questions of whether the assignment of less effective teachers contributes to worse short-term and longer-term outcomes for disadvantaged students. We leverage transfers of elementary teachers across schools in North Carolina to measure differences in teachers' effects on contemporaneous and future test scores according to students' socio-economic characteristics. We quantify the importance of these differences to account for the observed test score gaps between disadvantaged and advantaged students. Variation in teacher quality accounts for 3% of the total variation in contemporaneous test scores. We also find that teacher quality accounts for similar proportions when we consider variability in test scores taken two and three years after. Our estimates are robust to bias-correction methods that account for limited mobility bias."--Pages viii-ix.

Essays in Economics of Education

Essays in Economics of Education
Author: David Martinez De Lafuente
Publisher:
Total Pages: 146
Release: 2021
Genre: Education
ISBN:

This thesis consists of three independent essays in economics of education. In the first chapter, I investigate the connection between cultural identities and parental schooling decisions. By leveraging the case of the Basque Country (Spain), this essay studies how parents trade off academic quality for being educated in the regional language. Using a discrete choice structural model, I show that households display strong preferences for the Basque-monolingual model. Results indicate a willingness to forego a substantial amount of mean academic performance to evade the Spanish and the bilingual models. By means of regression analysis, I find a strong association between nationalistic voting and educational language choices. This suggests that schooling decisions are significantly shaped by parents' affiliation to the regional culture. In the second chapter, I test whether the cultural assimilation efforts of immigrant families mitigate discriminatory attitudes of schools. To this end, I sent fictitious visit requests to more than 2,500 schools located in the Community of Madrid (Spain). I find that Romanian families who gave a Spanish name to their child are 50% less discriminated than those who selected a Romanian name. Emails from families whose members have Romanian names are 12% less likely to receive a response than those from native Spanish-name families. The results show a consistent response pattern across school characteristics. The third chapter, co-authored with Lucas Gortazar and Ainhoa Vega-Bayo, studies the presence of systematic differences between teacher non-blind assessments and external quasiblindly graded standardized tests. We use a rich administrative database covering two cohorts from publicly-funded schools in the Basque Country. We find that systematic underassessment exists for boys, children with immigrant origin, and poorer students. The results indicate that stereotyping is a consistent mechanism through which our findings can be interpreted.