Empirical Implications of Analyst Forecast Dispersion to the Information Dynamics of Valuation Models

Empirical Implications of Analyst Forecast Dispersion to the Information Dynamics of Valuation Models
Author: Daniel M. Bryan
Publisher:
Total Pages:
Release: 2015
Genre:
ISBN:

Ohlson (1995) models firm value as a function of abnormal earnings, net book value and other unspecified information. Ohlson (2001) proposes consensus analyst forecasts as a proxy for the previously unspecified other information in his model, which we test using a two stage approach. The first stage identifies information in analyst forecasts that is reflected in current earnings and net book value, and the second stage regresses the first-stage residuals as the proxy for other new information. Our initial results using price-levels regressions concur with Dechow et al.'s (1999) findings that short-run consensus analyst forecasts are effective proxies for other information, and that the proposed model is no more descriptive than capitalizing short-run forecasts in perpetuity. We find that with high forecast dispersion, however, the effectiveness of analyst forecasts as well as the association between earnings and market values are diminished. Overall, we find that the descriptive ability of both the Ohlson model and the capitalized forecast model is dampened with high forecast dispersion, but the dampening is more severe for the capitalized forecast model, suggesting that the descriptive ability of Ohlson's valuation framework is strongest, relative to capitalized analyst forecasts, when uncertainty and information asymmetry are most severe. In contrast to our (and Dechow et al.'s) price-levels regression results, we find with returns regressions that Ohlson's model is consistently and significantly more descriptive than a model that simply capitalizes changes in analyst forecasts.

The Influence of Forecast Dispersion on the Incremental Explanatory Power of Earnings, Book Value and Analyst Forecasts on Market Prices

The Influence of Forecast Dispersion on the Incremental Explanatory Power of Earnings, Book Value and Analyst Forecasts on Market Prices
Author: Daniel M. Bryan
Publisher:
Total Pages:
Release: 2006
Genre:
ISBN:

This study investigates the influence of analyst forecast dispersion on Ohlson's (2001) proposed linear information dynamics where consensus analyst forecasts are suggested as a proxy for other information. Our results indicate that Ohlson's proposed valuation model is most descriptive of market pricing when forecast dispersion, and hence information asymmetry is high. Our results also suggest that when analysts are confronted with high information asymmetry, they tend to focus less on accounting fundamentals and rely more on other non-accounting information, thus decreasing the correlation between the explanatory power of analyst forecasts and that of earnings and book value.

Empirical Models of Analyst Forecasts

Empirical Models of Analyst Forecasts
Author: Youfei Xiao
Publisher:
Total Pages:
Release: 2016
Genre:
ISBN:

This dissertation is comprised of two studies on analyst forecasts. The first study provides empirical evidence about the objective function underlying analysts' choice of forecasts. Assumptions about sell-side analysts' objective function are critical to empirical researchers' understanding of their incentives and resulting behavior. In contrast to approaches used in previous papers which rely exclusively on statistical properties of forecasts, I compare theoretical models with alternate objective functions based on their ability to explain observed forecasts. A linear loss objective function which incorporates the effect future analysts' actions on analysts' deviation from peer forecasts is best rationalized by the data. I find that assumptions about the objective function have a substantial impact on the conclusions from empirical tests about analysts' incentives and behavior. The second study provides empirical estimates of uncertainty and disagreement about future earnings that underly analyst forecast dispersion. A parsimonious model which assumes that analysts' payoffs are jointly determined by forecast error and deviation from consensus reproduces many of the descriptive facts observed about forecast dispersion in the data. The strategic behavior that arises from the model distorts both the levels of forecast dispersion and the sensitivity of the measure with respect to cross-sectional variation in uncertainty. The estimated parameters perform better at predicting forecast dispersion out-of-sample than approaches based solely on regressions that use firm characteristics. Counterfactual simulations indicate that analysts' strategic incentives, together with the sequential forecast setting, plays a first-order role in determining forecast dispersion relative to the firm's information environment. The model-implied estimates of earnings uncertainty exhibit a substantially less negative association with future returns relative to the association generated by forecast dispersion. This finding partially reconciles the findings from previous studies with theories about the asset pricing implications of uncertainty and disagreement.

Financial Gatekeepers

Financial Gatekeepers
Author: Yasuyuki Fuchita
Publisher: Brookings Institution Press
Total Pages: 216
Release: 2007-02-01
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 0815729820

A Brookings Institution Press and Nomura Institute of Capital Markets Research publication Developed country capital markets have devised a set of institutions and actors to help provide investors with timely and accurate information they need to make informed investment decisions. These actors have become known as "financial gatekeepers" and include auditors, financial analysts, and credit rating agencies. Corporate financial reporting scandals in the United States and elsewhere in recent years, however, have called into question the sufficiency of the legal framework governing these gatekeepers. Policymakers have since responded by imposing a series of new obligations, restrictions, and punishments—all with the purpose of strengthening investor confidence in these important actors. Financial Gatekeepers provides an in-depth look at these new frameworks, especially in the United States and Japan. How have they worked? Are further refinements appropriate? These are among the questions addressed in this timely and important volume. Contributors include Leslie Boni (University of New Mexico), Barry Bosworth (Brookings Institution), Tomoo Inoue (Seikei University), Zoe-Vonna Palmrose (University of Southern California), Frank Partnoy (University of San Diego School of Law), George Perry (Brookings Institution), Justin Pettit (UBS), Paul Stevens (Investment Company Institute), Peter Wallison (American Enterprise Institute).

Estimating the Cost of Capital Implied by Market Prices and Accounting Data

Estimating the Cost of Capital Implied by Market Prices and Accounting Data
Author: Peter Easton
Publisher: Now Publishers Inc
Total Pages: 148
Release: 2009
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 1601981945

Estimating the Cost of Capital Implied by Market Prices and Accounting Data focuses on estimating the expected rate of return implied by market prices, summary accounting numbers, and forecasts of earnings and dividends. Estimates of the expected rate of return, often used as proxies for the cost of capital, are obtained by inverting accounting-based valuation models. The author describes accounting-based valuation models and discusses how these models have been used, and how they may be used, to obtain estimates of the cost of capital. The practical appeal of accounting-based valuation models is that they focus on the two variables that are commonly at the heart of valuations carried out by equity analysts -- forecasts of earnings and forecasts of earnings growth. The question at the core of this monograph is -- How can these forecasts be used to obtain an estimate of the cost of capital? The author examines the empirical validity of the estimates based on these forecasts and explores ways to improve these estimates. In addition, this monograph details a method for isolating the effect of any factor of interest (such as cross-listing, fraud, disclosure quality, taxes, analyst following, accounting standards, etc.) on the cost of capital. If you are interested in understanding the academic literature on accounting-based estimates of expected rate of return this monograph is for you. Estimating the Cost of Capital Implied by Market Prices and Accounting Data provides a foundation for a deeper comprehension of this literature and will give a jump start to those who have an interest in these topics. The key ideas are introduced via examples based on actual forecasts, accounting information, and market prices for listed firms, and the numerical examples are based on sound algebraic relations.

Equity Valuation Using Multiples

Equity Valuation Using Multiples
Author: Andreas Schreiner
Publisher: Springer Science & Business Media
Total Pages: 191
Release: 2009-04-15
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 3835095315

Andreas Schreiner examines the role of multiples in equity valuation. He transforms the standard multiples valuation method into a comprehensive framework for using multiples in valuation practice, which corresponds to economic theory and is consistent with the results of a broad empirical study of European and U.S. equity markets.

Commodity Price Dynamics

Commodity Price Dynamics
Author: Craig Pirrong
Publisher: Cambridge University Press
Total Pages: 239
Release: 2011-10-31
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 1139501976

Commodities have become an important component of many investors' portfolios and the focus of much political controversy over the past decade. This book utilizes structural models to provide a better understanding of how commodities' prices behave and what drives them. It exploits differences across commodities and examines a variety of predictions of the models to identify where they work and where they fail. The findings of the analysis are useful to scholars, traders and policy makers who want to better understand often puzzling - and extreme - movements in the prices of commodities from aluminium to oil to soybeans to zinc.

Bounded Rationality in Economics and Finance

Bounded Rationality in Economics and Finance
Author: Christian Richter
Publisher: LIT Verlag Münster
Total Pages: 197
Release: 2008
Genre: Capital market
ISBN: 3825816141

The dominant hypothesis in mainstream economics is the assumption of prefect rationality. However, there are two dilemmas: Whenever this assumption was used empirical evidence turned out to be against it. Secondly, this assumption is far from reality, for example, because individuals usually do not possess all relevant information. Therefore, this volume addresses issues of bounded rationality in different areas. The first part investigates bounded rationality in financial markets, the second part investigates the effects of bounded rationality on industrial organizations and the third part deals with bounded rationality in price theory, environmental economics and public management.