Piercing the Corporate Veil

Piercing the Corporate Veil
Author: Michala Rudorfer
Publisher: GRIN Verlag
Total Pages: 65
Release: 2009-07
Genre: Law
ISBN: 3640383796

Seminar paper from the year 2006 in the subject Law - Civil / Private / Trade / Anti Trust Law / Business Law, grade: A (1,0), New York University School of Law, language: English, abstract: Corporate law aims at protecting shareholders from being subject to personal liability for the risks of conducting business. The state created a corporate fiction which is a separate legal entity and distinctive from the shareholders and which offers the primary advantage of limited share-holder liability. The underlying notion is to encourage shareholders to provide capital and take on risky investments. In this way, the risk is shifted towards third parties and costs are external-ized. Overall, this investor attitude encourages economic development. Hence, limited liability can be seen as the "cornerstone of capitalism". However, as moral hazard comes into play, the externalization costs might exceed the benefits and, thus, damage third parties. In order to pro-mote justice, the presumption of limited liability must be occasionally rebutted and personal li-ability imposed on shareholders. This concept known as piercing the corporate veil will be elabo-rated on in detail in this paper. The doctrine is of crucial importance since it is the most litigated issue in corporate law. Regrettably, it is also among the most confusing areas of law. "'Pierc-ing' seems to happen freakishly. Like lightening, it is rare, severe, and unprincipled." The objective of this paper is to lift the confusion of the doctrine and answer the question whether piercing the corporate veil is a sound concept. Moreover, it will be analyzed whether it is the pre-vailing alternative in dealing with the moral hazard problem of limited liability. Therefore, Part I will start with an explanation of piercing and the historical development of the doctrine. Competing doctrines of piercing will be presented and form the basis for the subsequent analysis of the main requirements for piercing. To illustrate the applica

Piercing the Corporate Veil

Piercing the Corporate Veil
Author: Michala Rudorfer
Publisher: GRIN Verlag
Total Pages: 30
Release: 2009-07-27
Genre: Law
ISBN: 3640383818

Seminar paper from the year 2006 in the subject Law - Civil / Private, Trade, Anti Trust Law, Business Law, grade: A (1,0), New York University School of Law, language: English, abstract: Corporate law aims at protecting shareholders from being subject to personal liability for the risks of conducting business. The state created a corporate fiction which is a separate legal entity and distinctive from the shareholders and which offers the primary advantage of limited share-holder liability. The underlying notion is to encourage shareholders to provide capital and take on risky investments. In this way, the risk is shifted towards third parties and costs are external-ized. Overall, this investor attitude encourages economic development. Hence, limited liability can be seen as the “cornerstone of capitalism”. However, as moral hazard comes into play, the externalization costs might exceed the benefits and, thus, damage third parties. In order to pro-mote justice, the presumption of limited liability must be occasionally rebutted and personal li-ability imposed on shareholders. This concept known as piercing the corporate veil will be elabo-rated on in detail in this paper. The doctrine is of crucial importance since it is the most litigated issue in corporate law. Regrettably, it is also among the most confusing areas of law. “’Pierc-ing’ seems to happen freakishly. Like lightening, it is rare, severe, and unprincipled.” The objective of this paper is to lift the confusion of the doctrine and answer the question whether piercing the corporate veil is a sound concept. Moreover, it will be analyzed whether it is the pre-vailing alternative in dealing with the moral hazard problem of limited liability. Therefore, Part I will start with an explanation of piercing and the historical development of the doctrine. Competing doctrines of piercing will be presented and form the basis for the subsequent analysis of the main requirements for piercing. To illustrate the application of the doctrine, Part II will discuss four landmark cases. In Part III, the interplay of limited liability and veil-piercing will be as-sessed in different contexts of law. Afterwards, Part IV will elaborate the suitability of the con-cept compared to different alternatives. Finally, a conclusion will be drawn and the initial ques-tion will be answered. [...]

Piercing Corporate Veil

Piercing Corporate Veil
Author: Ashish Makhija
Publisher: LAP Lambert Academic Publishing
Total Pages: 76
Release: 2014-07-22
Genre:
ISBN: 9783659574436

The concept of piercing the corporate veil has always been the subject of legal discussion and analysis. One of the striking features of a corporate entity is its separate legal existence being a creature of law. The concept of piercing the corporate veil strikes at the basic feature of corporate existence and has been used across the globe to identify the persons operating and managing the corporates. Though this concept has a uniform applicability, the circumstances and situations under which the courts have used this principle differ. The principle of piercing corporate veil assumes greater significance in today's world with focus on eliminating transnational white-collar crimes using the facade of corporate veil. It calls for uniform dealing of the subject by countries. The focus of this work is the discussion of evolution of concept, governing principles, circumstances under which courts have used this concept, recent trends in this field, and recommendations based on comparative trends in US vis-a-vis India. This work seeks to understand and analyse the law relating to piercing/lifting the corporate veil in the United States and India.

Piercing the Corporate Veil Doctrine Under English Company Law After Prest V Petrodel Decision

Piercing the Corporate Veil Doctrine Under English Company Law After Prest V Petrodel Decision
Author: Ariel Mucha
Publisher:
Total Pages: 21
Release: 2018
Genre:
ISBN:

The Supreme Court case Prest v Petrodel Resources Ltd [2013] 2 AC 415 addresses the issue of whether, and if so in what way, the court is competent to pierce the corporate veil save any specific statutory authority to do so. In this context, Lord Sumption sheds further light on the doctrine of abuse of corporate personality under English law. Foremost, he draws a distinction between the evasion and concealment situations. The first involves situation, in which the person sets up the company with the aim of avoiding the prior obligation incumbent upon him or her. The second occurs when the relevant identity of “real actors” is hidden behind the corporate veil. In the Lord Sumption's opinion, only evasion may justify the application of the piercing the corporate veil doctrine. This article aims to find the rationale behind introduction of evasion and concealment principle, which seems to be the restriction of the piercing the corporate doctrine to the point where it will have no practical meaning for future cases.The Supreme Court case Prest v Petrodel Resources Ltd [2013] 2 AC 415 addresses the issue of whether, and if so in what way, the court is competent to pierce the corporate veil save any specific statutory authority to do so. In this context, Sumption LJ sheds further light on the doctrine of abuse of the company personality under English law. Foremost, he draws a blurred line between the concept of the piercing and lifting corporate veil. The intended strong limitation of the exception to the strict approach articulated in Salomon v A Salomon & Co Ltd [1897] A.C. 22 - separation of legal person from its shareholders and no prospects to make shareholder a party to the agreement concluded by the company - seems to be a failure yielding more doubts than providing a clearly articulated legal framework. This article argues against this approach and it suggests that the piercing veil doctrine needs to be forgotten once and for all.

Liability of Corporate Groups and Networks

Liability of Corporate Groups and Networks
Author: Christian A. Witting
Publisher: Cambridge University Press
Total Pages: 501
Release: 2018-01-11
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 1107039924

Discusses the nature of corporate groups and networks, and provides arguments for rules extending liability beyond insolvent entities.

Legal Capital in Europe

Legal Capital in Europe
Author: Marcus Lutter
Publisher: Walter de Gruyter
Total Pages: 716
Release: 2006
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 9783899493399

Europe has known very different systems of company laws for a long time. These differences do not only pertain to the board structures of public companies, where single-tier and two-tier structures can be distinguished, they also pertain to the principles of fixed legal capital. Fixed legal capital is not a traditional ingredient of English and Irish company law and had to be incorpo-rated into these legal systems (only) for public limited companies according to the Second European Company Law Directive of 1976. Both jurisdictions have never really embraced these rules. Against this background, the British Accounting Standards Board (ASB) and the Company Law Centre at the British Institute of International and Comparative Law (BIICL) have initiated and supported a study of the benefits of this legal system by a group of experts led by Jonathan Rickford. The report of this group has been published in 2004. Its result was that legal capital was costly and superfluous; hence, the Second Directive should be repealed. The British government has adopted this view and wants the European Commission to act accordingly. Against this background a group of German and European company law experts, academics as well as practitioners, have come together to scrutinise sense and benefits of fixed legal capital and all its specific elements guided by the following questions: What is the relevant legal concept supposed to achieve? What does it achieve in reality? What criticisms are there? Which proposals or alternatives are available? From the outset the group of experts has endeavoured to cooperate with foreign colleagues, which resulted in very fruitful and pleasant exchanges. This volume contains, besides an executive summary of the results, 16 essays on specific aspects of legal capital in Germany covering also neighbouring fields of law (e.g. accounting, insolvency);7 reports on fixed legal capital in other jurisdictions (France, Great Britain, Italy, the Netherlands, Poland, Spain and the U.S.A.) addressing the same questions as the essays on German law. The British initiative disapproves of the Second Directive. The Directive does only deal with public limited companies in Europe, which is reflected in the analysis presented here. It is only concerned with the fixed legal capital of public limited companies, not with capital issues of private companies. The study has arrived at a result that differs completely from that of the Rickford group. It verifies the usefulness of the concept of fixed legal capital and wishes to convince the European Commission of the benefits of the Second Company Law Directive.

Berlingieri on Arrest of Ships

Berlingieri on Arrest of Ships
Author: Francesco Berlingieri
Publisher: CRC Press
Total Pages: 874
Release: 2013-08-29
Genre: Law
ISBN: 1135117470

This book is an invaluable source of information about the claims in respect of which a ship may be arrested in the various maritime countries of the world, the conditions for obtaining an order of arrest, the need, if any, for a security, the manner by which the ship that has been arrested may be released, the possibility of a multiple arrest and the jurisdiction on the merits. Berlingieri provides an analysis and insightful commentary, on an article per article and paragraph per paragraph basis, of the 1952 International Convention for the Unification of Certain Rules Relating to the Arrest of Sea-Going Ships and the 1999 International Convention on Arrest of Ships (entering into force September 2011). New to this edition Updating of the information on the interpretation of the 1952 Convention in a number of Contracting States An analysis of the adoption of the rules of the 1999 Conventions in various States of the world, including China, the member States of the Communauté Économique et Monétaire de l’Afrique Centrale (Cameroon, Congo, Gabon, Tchad), the member States of the Comunidad Andina (Bolivia, Columbia, Ecuador and Peru) and Venezuela. This book is a useful reference tool for practitioners, as well as academics and post-graduate students of maritime law.