With Tyler's father on the mend, Kelsey and Tyler return to Seattle and find themselves thrust into the busy life of being Mr. and Mrs. Olsen. In the midst of all of their new obligations, Kelsey makes a bold promise, one that she believes is appropriate for a new wife. But what happens when she fails to keep it?

With the holidays over, Kelsey and Tyler are ready to focus back on their normal lives, which means lots of work, and lots of love. But just as the couple starts settling into the new year, a surprise guest leads to a shocking decision that changes everything.

Tyler and Kelsey cut their Italian honeymoon short to race back to New York City to be with Tyler’s father, who has been injured in an accident. When they arrive, they quickly discover that their new responsibilities are overwhelming, and the couple tries to make the most of the time they have together. But as family secrets are uncovered and feelings are expressed, Kelsey finds herself allied with the one person she never thought she would be able to understand.