Assessing Fishermen’s Perceptions of the Ecology and Management of the California North Coast Marine Protected Area Network

Assessing Fishermen’s Perceptions of the Ecology and Management of the California North Coast Marine Protected Area Network
Author: Lucia Ordonez-Gauger
Publisher:
Total Pages: 148
Release: 2015
Genre: Fishers
ISBN:

There is a growing body of research related to the human dimensions of MPAs, and research shows that social elements can be just as important to MPA success as the biological ones. This thesis describes research focused on the MPA network developed in the North Coast of California. The California Marine Life Protection Act was the state law to create one of the largest networks of Marine Protected Areas (MPAs) in the United States. Each network uses marine closures to attempt habitat restoration and creating refuge for exploited fish stocks. My research will provide information about fishermen’s perceptions of the management of the MPA network as well as their knowledge about the local fishery ecosystems and the functionality of MPAs. I worked collaboratively with fishermen to gather socioeconomic information about the network. Research is based on surveys of over 150 commercial fishermen, and five focus group conversations with 5-12 individuals the region’s five main ports. This work is a component to be integrated into a larger examination of the socioeconomic consequences of the Northern California MPAs. Results indicate there is a lack of trust in management regimes and a gap between local and scientific knowledge related to the function of MPA networks. This study’s findings also exemplify the need for improved trust and communication between fishermen and managers, and a more integrative system of management incorporating knowledge from local experts who are in these habitats daily and whose livelihoods depend directly upon marine ecosystem health.

The North California Coast Marine Protected Area Network

The North California Coast Marine Protected Area Network
Author: Felicia Noelle Simone Olmeta-Schult
Publisher:
Total Pages: 255
Release: 2018
Genre: Fishers
ISBN:

There has been rapid progress in the designation of marine protected areas (MPAs) in the past decade to restore biodiversity, enhance fisheries, and protect habitats and ecosystems via the restriction of human activities. However, conservation can be a highly controversial topic as it is located at the nexus of biodiversity, wellbeing and sustainability. In 2012, twenty MPAs were established along the North Coast of California as mandated by the 1999 Marine Life Protection Act (MLPA). As part of the MLPA Initiative, the California coast was divided into four study regions, the North Coast being the last one. A Regional Stakeholder Group (RSG) designed MPAs for each region following specific scientific guidelines. Our research objectives addressed the following issues: 1) how NCC commercial fishermen perceived MPAs effects on their livelihood and on natural resources; 2) how fishermen perceived the MPA planning process; and 3) how NCC RSG members agreed on a unified proposal for the designation of MPAs. To accomplish this, we conducted surveys and focus groups with commercial fishermen in six northern California fishing ports, and semi-structured interviews with actors directly involved in the MPA planning process. Findings for Chapter 1 showed that most commercial fishermen perceived MPAs as negatively affecting them, the loss of fishing grounds being the main effect. Most fishermen did not believe that the new closures would help in improving the health of natural resources. Perceptions of these effects varied between fisheries and ports. Results for Chapter 2 showed that most fishermen considered the MPA planning process high in conflict, were dissatisfied with it, and distrusted it. Others suggested that the planning process lacked legitimacy due to several reasons: outsiders leading the process, funding coming from environmental NGOs, and lack of familiarity and trust toward some agencies. Finally, findings for Chapter 3 showed that the development of a unified proposal was led by: the existence of multiple decision centers, the increased community capacity that led to increased communication, trust, social capital, and ultimately collective action, a small North Coast community, and the composition and size of the RSG.

Assessing California Commercial Fishing Community Well-being in the Context of Marine Protected Area (MPA) Formation

Assessing California Commercial Fishing Community Well-being in the Context of Marine Protected Area (MPA) Formation
Author: Samantha Cook (Graduate student)
Publisher:
Total Pages: 124
Release: 2021
Genre: Fisheries
ISBN:

Marine protected areas (MPAs)—defined geographic areas where fishing and harvesting activity is limited or restricted—have emerged as a popular marine biodiversity and climate resilience strategy worldwide. MPA monitoring efforts often follow MPA designation to help inform the adaptive management of MPAs and MPA networks. In 2012, California completed the largest statewide system of MPAs to date, consisting of 124 MPAs covering 16% of state waters. Following MPA implementation, the state initiated a long-term monitoring program (2019-2022) to help inform the 10-year MPA management review. This two-chapter thesis presents findings from a state-funded project to conduct long-term socioeconomic monitoring for human uses of the MPA network. Chapter 1 describes the novel methodological framework we developed to assess commercial fishing community well-being in relation to long-term MPA management in California. To address the need for standardized, contextual data—and the unique context, scale, and budget constraints of this study—we conducted mixed-methods focus groups with commercial fishing “community-experts” in 18 major California ports/port groups. The focus groups followed a structured, deliberative format that yielded both quantitative and qualitative data. Participants were asked to rate and discuss 15 questions related to fishing community well-being and outcomes from MPAs. Due to pandemic conditions at the time of data collection, focus groups were held over Zoom. Chapter 1 goes on to demonstrate the capabilities of the approach, including the type of data collected and adjustments made in light of the coronavirus pandemic, and discusses participant feedback on the virtual process and lessons learned from the project team’s perspective. Chapter 2 offers an in-depth exploration of the major findings gleaned from the focus group approach discussed in Chapter 1. Results indicated that fishing communities across California were experiencing challenges in their environmental, economic, and social well-being. Results did vary at the port/port group level, suggesting that well-being conditions were uneven across fishing communities. A majority of participants expressed negative views about ecological and livelihood outcomes of MPAs and dissatisfaction with the management of the California MPA network. While MPAs were not reported as the cause of the well-being challenges revealed in the results, focus group data suggested MPAs had interacted with and—in many cases—exacerbated pre-existing well-being challenges, many of which had arisen from structural shortcomings in California fisheries. This study contributes to the growing yet small literature and methodologies on the linkage between community well-being and MPAs, and demonstrates the strengths and capabilities of using a well-being approach for long-term socioeconomic monitoring and adaptive management of MPAs and MPA networks like that in California.

The Benefits of Marine Protected Areas

The Benefits of Marine Protected Areas
Author: Australian Government - Department of the Environment and Heritage - Environment Australia
Publisher:
Total Pages: 20
Release: 2003
Genre: Environmental protection
ISBN: 9780642549495

The Fisherman's Problem

The Fisherman's Problem
Author: Arthur F. McEvoy
Publisher: Cambridge University Press
Total Pages: 392
Release: 1986
Genre: Business & Economics
ISBN: 9780521385862

A critical appraisal of California's fishing industry management develops from an interdisciplinary compilation of recent research in law, economics, marine biology and anthropology.

Marine Managed Areas and Fisheries

Marine Managed Areas and Fisheries
Author:
Publisher: Academic Press
Total Pages: 447
Release: 2014-10-27
Genre: Science
ISBN: 0128003324

Advances in Marine Biology has been providing in-depth and up-to-date reviews on all aspects of marine biology since 1963--over 40 years of outstanding coverage! The series is well known for its excellent reviews and editing. Now edited by Michael Lesser (University of New Hampshire, USA) with an internationally renowned Editorial Board, the serial publishes in-depth and up-to-date content on many topics that will appeal to postgraduates and researchers in marine biology, fisheries science, ecology, zoology, and biological oceanography. Volumes cover all areas of marine science, both applied and basic, a wide range of topical areas from all areas of marine ecology, oceanography, fisheries management and molecular biology and the full range of geographic areas from polar seas to tropical coral reefs. This volume, with an introduction by Ray Hilborn, will present the latest views on the use of MPAs or Marine Managed Areas for fisheries management. It will contain a wide range of case studies including the Chagos archipelago, South Georgia, the Caribbean, the North Sea, Florida, Hawaii, Great Barrier Reef, California, Mediterraneanand the Phoenix Islands Protected Area. It is the intention of the editors that the volume presents a series of evidence based rather than advocacy driven contemporary reviews. AMB volumes solicit and publish review articles on the latest advances in marine biology Many of the authors of these review articles are the leading figures in their field of study and the material is widely used by managers, students and academic professionals in the marine sciences

Evaluating Relative Abundance, Fish Length, and Marine Protected Area Effectiveness for Four Key Rocky Reef Species Along the Northern Californian Coast

Evaluating Relative Abundance, Fish Length, and Marine Protected Area Effectiveness for Four Key Rocky Reef Species Along the Northern Californian Coast
Author: Leon Davis (Graduate student)
Publisher:
Total Pages: 97
Release: 2022
Genre: Lingcod
ISBN:

Marine protected areas (MPAs) were created with the purpose of helping conserve and restore diminished populations of marine organisms. Measuring the effectiveness of MPAs requires long-term monitoring, investigating the abundance and size distributions of the species that utilize the conservation areas, and comparing the results to neighboring reference sites that are not currently protected. In this study, observations from long-term MPA monitoring in northern California (2010-2019) were modeled with substrate, oceanographic, spatial, temporal, and body size variables to describe the variability in abundance and size of three fish groups: Black rockfish (Sebastes melanops), the Blue rockfish group (comprised of Blue rockfish (Sebastes mystinus) and Deacon rockfish (Sebastes diaconus)), and Lingcod (Ophiodon elongatus). Models were also used to explain the differences in the abundance and size associated with protection status (MPA vs. reference). The data consisted of two MPAs and their paired reference sites (accessed from the ports of Eureka and Fort Bragg, CA), and another set of two auxiliary reference sites north of Trinidad, CA that were not paired with an MPA. Lagged oceanographic covariates had strong relationships with relative abundance of Black rockfish and illustrated the importance of upwelling as a long-lasting driver of adult relative abundance. Lagged oceanographic effects could be products of the long-term effects that upwelling has on recruitment. Substrate covariates and distance to port played an important role in describing the variability in relative abundance and length of the species, while substantiating previous studies. Weak, but detectable, effects of protection status on abundances of lingcod and lengths of all species were also found. The presence of detectable signals indicates that the MPAs within this study are beginning to positively influence abundances and lengths of the fish that reside within them, further supporting their utility and functionality as tools of conservation that can be used by fisheries managers. This study adds general information and critical insight into the population dynamics, environmental drivers, and management effectiveness of the species studied, along the California North Coast.